Both are true, IMO.
Even if it was relevent, firing rockets into space doesnt somehow mean the moronic shitposts you make suddenly don't exist.
And finally "i'm" not saying anything, the guy sharts every other thought into his twitter megaphone. I'm just taking that feed at face value. Unless of course you now claim to speak for and translate on behalf of old Elon.
You can be a rich idiot and delegate the actual work to smart people, that isn't a contradiction.
What you are demonstrating is cognitive dissonance, because it is Elon Musk himself that is presenting himself in a negative light and then you somehow pin his own public behaviour on the media.
Indeed.
He does appear to be good at raising money, through a mixture of government subsidies and making things up to pump valuations. It's just that instead of Tesla's "self driving cars are coming next year" it's about missions to Mars. (You could argue that this is similar Steve Jobs' reality distortion field, except... Apple actually delivered.)
But even if Musk had a hand in things, professional success does validate unwell behavior. Howard Hughes was a successful aircraft engineer despite, but clearly suffered from severe mental illness. The difference is that Hughs lived out his decline in private, while Musk is live-tweeting his unraveling.
Then people pretend his behavior is "unwell" or "unhinged". Then I ask them "how is he unhinged" and I get a long confusing rant about nonsense. Personally I prefer progress over a popularity. Nerds are just bullying nerds at this point.
I think you are the bully here.
I never mentioned a failed SpaceX launch.
Imagine describing Musk’s behavior to a stranger while leaving out a name: Impulsively buying a beleaguered business, then destroying its only revenue through further impulsivity. Would a well person in his situation give the recent, “Go Fuck Yourself” speech to advertisers?
Your believes about his “behavior” will make you if it happens. That will be the rationalization. An ad hominem attack.
Musk’s can tell advertisers to go fuck themselves. Lots of other companies do. Valve is probably the most successful example.
I don’t see how Valve is analogous. Perhaps if they were in a financial nosedive, and turned around and told software publishers to go fuck themselves?
This is just factually wrong.
Musk has been leading and controlling SpaceX for literally 20 years now. He has always been in full control and made pretty much all the most important decisions. He hired and recruited all of the leadership team. And he did work on the design and and helped build the rocket too. Since when is leading a team not important? Those are simple facts. Go read about about Falcon 1.
Its Twitter where Musk only recently started on, and Twitter had lots of issues before Musk took over, and Twitter where he has put a CEO in place.
So the fact is, Musk is far more deeply involved in SpaceX compared to Twitter. The same for Tesla, Musk has just as much power there and its also very successful.
The whole 'its all fund raising and government' doesn't actually hold up either.
> Apple actually delivered
Being the most successful space company in history. Having the most rocket launches, the biggest rocket, the most reliable engine, the most advanced engine, the most sats and the most launched human isn't good enough for you? Hasn't even deliver on the most complex project in human history. What a loser.
Granted its not exactly as complex as having a computer with a nice user-interface ...
> while Musk is live-tweeting his unraveling.
Musk is fine, he lives on, he does the same things he has been doing for 20+ years, SpaceX and Tesla continue to do fine and he is continuing to lead them. Twitter, exists and works fine. If that is 'unraveling' then I don't think you know what that words means.
All that has actually happened because of this 'unraveling' is that Twitter lost some of its value. Not ideal but also not really a big deal either.
Essentially calling somebody mentally ill because you don't like how they handle a company is really is more a reflection on you not Musk.
Factually wrong? Are you saying that Musk designs and builds the rockets?
> Musk has been leading and controlling SpaceX for literally 20 years now.
I think his behavior has very clearly changed over the past 20 years. There's a theory the pandemic did something to him, but I suspect it predates that.
> Being the most successful space company in history. Having the most rocket launches, the biggest rocket, the most reliable engine, the most advanced engine, the most sats and the most launched human isn't good enough for you? Hasn't even deliver on the most complex project in human history. What a loser.
I didn't call him a loser, and I'm not sure why you're equating criticism with an ad-hominem attack. I genuinely think he is grappling with mental health issues, though it doesn't excuse his behavior.
Anyway, I don't think it's relevant to dig into SpaceX's engineering any more than Tesla's battery tech.
If I hire a contractor to renovate my bathroom, and the results are good, is it because I had a hand in it? For all you know, I could have changed my mind about the tiles halfway through and demanded they start over, making the project harder than it needed to be. I could have hurled abuse at the laborer and the stiffed him for the bill.
> Musk is fine, he lives on, he does the same things he has been doing for 20+ years, SpaceX and Tesla continue to do fine and he is continuing to lead them.
Howard Hughes' companies did fine through his mental decline and death.
> Twitter, exists and works fine. If that is 'unraveling' then I don't think you know what that words means.
Twitter has lost its only major source of revenue, most of the people I followed there have moved on, and it's facing so many lawsuits that I've lost count. That doesn't seem fine.
The important detail is that all of this was self inflicted. The company wasn't doing great, but it was chugging along. He grabbed the wheel and drove it straight into a wall.
> Essentially calling somebody mentally ill because you don't like how they handle a company is really is more a reflection on you not Musk.
I think that when someone acts mentally ill, they tend to be mentally ill. The only counterargument seems to boil down to, "But he has a lot of money."
Yes he did help to design and build the rockets. By literally any definition. His impact on the final products of SpaceX is clearly larger then anybody else at SpaceX. And if you actually read the books on the topic, listen to talks with people who worked with him rather then some anti-space socialists on twitter.
> I think his behavior has very clearly changed over the past 20 years.
Many people change over 20 years ... but he didn't really fundamentally. Buying twitter came at the end of years of talking about speech and so on.
> If I hire a contractor to renovate my bathroom, and the results are good, is it because I had a hand in it?
Containing with the nonsense of 'he is just the finance' guy. Again, just nonsense. Honestly, inform yourself.
> most of the people I followed there have moved on
Its called selection bias.
> and it's facing so many lawsuits that I've lost count
Welcome to america.
> but it was chugging along.
And it still is.
> He grabbed the wheel and drove it straight into a wall.
How about we judge the company 5 or 10 years after he takes control. Tesla was a shitshow when he took over as well.
Twitter will likely never have the absurd valuation it had before, but to claim it 'drove into a wall' just isn't accurate.
> I think that when someone acts mentally ill, they tend to be mentally ill.
Again, I love to know what he has actually done that constitutes 'act mentally ill'. You can point to lots of things that make him not very like-able, but those aren't the same thing.
Literally your only argument seems to be 'twitter is now worth less then when he bought it'. So you think any company that gets acquired and doesn't justify its value means the CEO who bought it is mentally ill? Was Balmer mentally ill when he bought Nokia?
But go to now that you are professional therapist who can make medical diagnosis.
> The only counterargument seems to boil down to, "But he has a lot of money."
That's literally zero % of the argument but I guess that is what you need to tell yourself for your reasoning to make sense. He is rich because he is rich, and he is crazy because he wastes money on things you don't find important.
Do you think he had a greater impact than Tom Mueller? I'd expect the guy who was lead on the TR-106, and already developing liquid-fueled rocket engines, had more technical impact at a space company than a guy who worked in e-payments.
> And if you actually read the books on the topic, listen to talks with people who worked with him rather then some anti-space socialists on twitter.
I find it fascinating that you use "books" in the plural, like a totally normal person would read multiple books on Elon Musk.
From my survey of the material, Elon Musk books fail to consider anything he does from a critical perspective. Perhaps that's a requirement of getting access to interviews, or perhaps the authors know their audience are parasocial fans. Are there any books that you recommend that take a critical look?
> How about we judge the company 5 or 10 years after he takes control. Tesla was a shitshow when he took over as well.
Was it? It seems Tesla was any early-stage company. When he took over Twitter, it was already making revenue and even reached profitability in 2019. I don't understand the endgame of driving advertisers away.
> Again, I love to know what he has actually done that constitutes 'act mentally ill'.
It's hard to pick just one, but I'd start with the Twitter acquisition. Specifically, the part where he felt insulted by the CEO, so he initiated a hostile takeover. Then he put together a contract that he couldn't back out of. Then he spent much of the year trying to back out of that contract by just making up silly excuses.
Following the transition, he has cultivated an image and a platform that no sane advertiser would touch with a ten foot pole. Would a person grounded in reality tell a room full of advertisers, "Go fuck yourself," and then pause for applause that never come?
Then there's all the behavior in his personal life. I'm an open minded person, so if you want to have children with two women at the same time... and everyone is a consulting adult... good luck? But not telling both women what was going on seems unwell.
If you described this behavior to someone while leaving out the names, they'd probably describe it as self-destructive.
> But go to now that you are professional therapist who can make medical diagnosis.
It doesn't take a medical professional to watch bizarre episodes by Kanye West, Charlie Sheen or Britney Spears, and know something is up. I won't venture to say Elon is bipolar or has a drug problem, but if the news came out, most people would react with, "Sounds right."
Don't fall all over yourself moving the goal post. That's dangerous.
> normal person would read multiple books on Elon Musk
Books on EV, rockets, SpaceX, Tesla ...
But thanks for admitting that you are not actually informed. It shows.
> Was it?
Again, read some books.
> It's hard to pick just one
You have one, its bad business choices. Bad business choices don't imply mentally ill.
I don't think you know what moving the goal post means.
In my original post, I said, "Musk doesn't design or build the rockets."
You just said, "His impact on the final products of SpaceX is clearly larger than anybody else at SpaceX," and you claimed, "And he did work on the design and and helped build the rocket too."
I asked if that includes Tom Mueller, the person with professional experience designing rockets. Because going from "fired by an e-payments company" to "designing rockets" is quite a pivot.
> Books on EV, rockets, SpaceX, Tesla ...
What books do you recommend?
> But thanks for admitting that you are not actually informed.
I like to think I'm informed because I listen to both the praise and criticism of Musk and then make up my own mind.
> You have one, its bad business choices. Bad business choices don't imply mentally ill.
Are you saying that driving away all the advertisers, in the way that he did, was a business choice? Can you explain what he hoped to accomplish?
What I see is a mountain of evidence you can't argue with, so your only hope is an appeal to authority.
You believe he is smart. I presented an example of a stupid act. Now you’re supposed to explain why he did that. I’d think the only explanation would be a genius strategy I’m missing, but you seem to have trouble explaining it.
That said, I’m still genuinely interested in what you find loaded about my questions.
Do you disagree that advertisers left? Do you disagree that he was responsible? Do you disagree that this was a bad turn of events?