>These costs have to be capitalized and amortized over 5 years – or 15 if labor is done outside of the US.
I’m not an accountant so maybe I’m reading that wrong, but if so that’s insane.
>These costs have to be capitalized and amortized over 5 years – or 15 if labor is done outside of the US.
I’m not an accountant so maybe I’m reading that wrong, but if so that’s insane.
You essentially pay taxes now on income, and can’t deduct costs for 5 or 15 years. So it’s kind of like pre-paying taxes and not getting the money back for 5/15 years. Say that you need to go borrow cash to cover the shortfall. Is it cheaper to borrow money for 5 or 15 years?
If my business makes 400k/year, but I pay a contractor 100k during that year, my effective income is reduced by 100k.
The recent changes mean you can still do that for most staff EXCEPT developers, even if the devs are doing operational work instead of work that feels more conventionally like R&D. So you have to come up with a bundle of cash now to pay tax on most of the developers’ salaries, even though they’ll give it back to you over 5-15 years.
Essentially you making a free loan to the government for a decade or whatever, except the money’s probably not free to you.
Of course I can think of situations where the development effort really was more R&D than operational, and the revenue stream matched: the first few years operated at a loss already, and the deductions might have more been useful in 5 years when the revenues were flowing in from a mature product. But I think they might have ways to carry forward losses to future tax years or something to deal with situations like that?
Because it is an expense maybe?
* Total Revenue: $1,000,000
* Cost of food: -$200,000
* Employee Salary: -$600,000
* (potential profit): $200,000
Assuming you can deduct the cost of food and employee salary to sling your burgers.. you make a 200k profit, and pay taxes on 200k.
But now let's say you can't deduct employee salary. You now pay taxes on $800,000 of income despite only having $200,000 of income. Depending on tax rates etc. you might end up with $0 in your pocket, despite having a successful business.
Now replace McDonalds with bootstrapped startup, food cost with AWS bill, and keep employee cost. This is the real situation many small SaaS or other software companies are currently in.
You can see how if this was 5 years, then I could deduct 1/5 and I would be taxed on $120k profit, which is still bad, but not nearly as bad.
The easy example is a car company, like Ford. If they buy a car factory, that is a capital asset, and the cost needs to be amortized over x years. If they decide to instead BUILD a car factory...they still end up with a capital asset, and the costs (including wages) need to be amortized over x years.
In most cases this is what companies want - they'll have revenues over x years and matching costs over x years is generally better for everyone.
E.g. if you pay $150K for local research, you expense $15K (10%) the first year (and 30K the subsequent year). You pay taxes on $135K of 'profit'. Let's say that's $45K (I have no idea what's realistic here.
Alternately you pay $130K for a dev from Canada, expense $4,333 (1/30) the first year, and pay tax on the remaining 'profit' of $125,666. Even after admin costs you're coming out ahead
This way, all the R&D expenses are happening in Canada.
My feeling is that an EoR (employer of record) like remote.com might be enough for everyone to be able to avoid R&D capitalization. The research happens in Canada, by a Canadian employee of a Canadian company. You pay an American company for outsourcing human resources. The American company pays the Canadian company for human resources services.
Then again, if you're paying another company for outsourced human resouces, but you have an IP assignment clause as part of that, maybe you would need to claim it as your R&D expense