Why is it that when we talk about making search better many (seriously, like gobs of people) talk like the only way to improve it is to overthrow Google. Improvements in search can come from anywhere. If Google can deliver on what the author talks about then that's great. If someone else can then that's great too. The point is to improve search not overthrow Google's dominance, right?
I'm all for the ideas in this article but I was totally turned off by the subtext that implied a need to take down Google. We don't really need a next Google. Google can be the next Google. It doesn't matter so long as the hidden web is indexed.
Why is it that as soon as a company is no longer the underdog we immediately throw them under the bus. Microsoft made PCs the norm in US households and now we love to tear them down (rightly so in many cases, admittedly). Facebook used to be the coolest thing ever and now we love to hate them too. Same with Google and Apple. Why do we hate incumbents so badly?
In any case, yes, let's index that hidden web. But let's focus on the indexing itself rather than who does it. If Google succeeds at doing this will it not count and will we still call for someone else to "disrupt" the new hidden web indexing industry?