Now, if the original copyrighted work can be extracted or reproduced from the model, that’s obviously copyright infringement.
OpenAI etc should ensure they don’t do that.
Now, if the original copyrighted work can be extracted or reproduced from the model, that’s obviously copyright infringement.
OpenAI etc should ensure they don’t do that.
If OpenAI's output reproduces a copyrighted image with one pixel changed, is that valid in your view? Where does the line end?
Copyrighted material should never be used for nonacademic language models. "Garbage in, garbage out." All results are tainted.
"But being forced to use non-copyrighted works will only slow things down!"
Maybe that's a good thing, too. Copyright is something every industry has to accept and deal with -- LLMs don't get a "cool tech, do whatever" get-out-of-jail free card.
By virtue of the fact that it is "fuzzy" and open to interpretation, we're going to see lawsuits, the resulting chilling effects of those lawsuits will blunt US tech firms from the practice of ingesting large amounts of copywritten material without a second thought. US tech firms will be giving it a second, third, fourth, etc. thought once the lawsuits start.
It's gonna be like submarine patents on steroids.
Like I said, I'm down for letting the courts decide. But AI supporters should probably avoid kicking the hornets' nests regarding copyright.
Whatever the standard is for humans doing the exact same thing.
I think there's an important distinction to be made here - "can" be reproduced isn't infringement, only actual reproduction is (and degrees thereof not consisting of sufficiently transformative or fair use).
Trivially a typewriter can reproduce a copyrighted book. Less trivially Google books, with iirc stores the full text of copywrited works has been judged to be legal.