Looks more like a systemic issue in the Rust development process to me tbh.
What's more shocking though is that even after a 90% size reduction, a vanilla hello world is still 415 KBytes. That's about 10..100x bigger than I would expect from a low level "systems programming language".
Also, Rust has no direct platform support unlike C. So everything has to be statically linked to be portable. A statically linked glibc is indeed much larger than that (~800 KB in my machine). Conversely, you can sacrifice portability and link to `libstd*.so` dynamically to get a very small binary (~17 KB in my machine, both for C and Rust).
For instance a statically linked C hello world for Linux via MUSL (cross-compiled with `zig cc -Os -target x86_64-linux-musl hello.c -o hello` because I'm currently on a Mac) is just 5 KBytes.
[1] https://www.gnu.org/software/libc/manual/html_node/Backtrace...
That happens all the time, it's called prioritizing. If you don't let people prioritize, they will burn out and leave the project. That's not what you want.
Because in the end almost nobody actually cares about it enough to create a fix.
Small binaries are great, but people care mainly about how fast it compiles and how fast it runs, and in the few cases where the binary size is important it was already possible to shrink it significantly (more than with this new change). In my entire life I have never heard a user complain about the size of the binary, what people really care about is efficiency/speed at runtime. That's why people regularly mention VS Code using Electron, but not that its installation package alone has >500MB.
C was created in a time when binary sizes used to be important for every program. These days, it only matters for a small subset of use cases.
If anything, the fact that no one fixed it for this long is an indicator that it doesn't matter much for the kinds of things people typically build with rust.
It's nice that there's a fix now, but would I care if Firefox or Chrome binary was 4MB bigger?
The `strip` was added to rust nightly in 2020.
1: https://github.com/johnthagen/min-sized-rust
2: https://kerkour.com/optimize-rust-binary-size
3: https://rustrepo.com/repo/johnthagen-min-sized-rust
4: https://sing.stanford.edu/site/publications/rust-lctes22.pdf
5: https://arusahni.net/blog/2020/03/optimizing-rust-binary-siz...