In general fq_codel is superior to pie in just about every way. There is a specific thing that pie does that makes it appealing to hardware designers is that it is O(1) on egress and fq_codel is not (but there are ways around that). fq_codel achieves less latency than pie does, and faster than it does. codel takes a bit longer than we would like.
fq-pie still has worse tcp latency (using the same fq algorithm as in fq_codel and cake), and cake solves all kinds of edge cases that no other fq+aqm+shaper can - per host FQ (solving torrent issues), ack-filtering, nat transparency, a better codel model, easy to use link layer compensation, diffserv - and my favorite feature is actually that it runs more or less the same as a default qdisc, as a shaped one. I had hoped it would replace fq_codel at both line rate and at the shaped cases, but it did prove a bit too cpu intensive on cheesy hardware and the edge cases not noticeable enough on simple benchmarks.
I would like to multi-thread it, and add some new features, discussion here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tTYBPeaRdCO9AGTGQCpoiuLO...