They have brand value, but less than a few years ago, which is when they should have reinvented. At this point they're close to the "Toys-R-Us" level of brand value: remembered by the previous generation, and seen as a relic by the current.
If a young person thinks of them at all, I imagine they're "that magazine that used to have a swimsuit edition."
Even then, the reputation with the previous generation was dented by SI trying to make the swimsuit issue more progressive (that's the only time I ever heard a peep about it from older relatives, not that they bought it in the first place), which didn't make the current generation care more about it.
What exactly do you mean by more progressive? [I've seen Sports Illustrated when I was young--but that was a long time ago.]
Attempting to be more inclusive about the types of models they feature.
It's mostly more inclusion of trans, plus-size, disabled, older, etc models, a lot of getting press with "first X cover model". It's a nice thought, but a lot of their usual audience was likely turned off.