Judge your Resume with AI: What's the worst that can happen?
medium.com
medium.com
The FTC just tore a retailer a 50mil new hole along with a 5 year order to ban the use of facial recognition software because they failed to ensure a non discriminatory environment by failing to validate AI software supplier claims about its performance.
This article does not even cover the most basic mitigation to take (which very well may be unsuitable) like removing PII (name, address). It’s trivial to prove that leaving these elements in can bias the output in various ways.
Can’t wait for every company to adopt the same AI snakeoil supplier for filtering applicants and then getting dragged into the inevitable class action with hot ugly discovery.
I'm more optimistic on this you and think AI can help with the hiring process. There's just too many applicants and good applicants fall through the cracks. This is also not all that new. HR has long had systems to try to bubble up good candidates. This will just make those better.
Currently, the best way to get in with a big tech company is knowing someone and working around the standard hiring process. How is that fair? Or how do we accept that most candidates never get a response? I'd argue there is a lot of room for improvement.
Technology rarely solves problems, at best it replaces them with different problems.
You also assume that the ultimate goal of hiring is supposed to be fair - but fair is just one parameter, a ballot would be fair, but it would fail to meet the companies only goal.
LLMs can also be used to run natural language queries against your candidate database (i.e. RAG).
Those are just two, plenty of other things. No one is going to read every incoming resume, ATS systems have been around a long time. I'm sure existing ATS systems have already added the term "AI-powered" to their marketing.
While AI is an overused term, there are certainly plenty of use cases to improve existing processes that are already happening.