How is that evil?
How is that evil?
"But still she was there, who was there before Sauron, and before the first stone of Barad-dûr; and she served none but herself, drinking the blood of Elves and Men, bloated and grown fat with endless brooding on her feasts, weaving webs of shadow; for all living things were her food, and her vomit darkness."
Now if you're interested in non-evil spiders I highly recommend deepness in the sky by Vernor Vinge.
Also we did enslaved our own, raped them, and killed them, pretending they were not intelligent and didn't have a soul.
We do eat octopus, which have demonstrated level of intelligence close to a human child.
Also, suffering is not proportional to intelligence, are you evil because you make life suffers, or because it understands how you do it ?
I don't think it's that clear cut. And I'm not sure we would stop to eat beef if tomorrow somebody proved they are quite smart.
The orgies of meat we bath into based on factories that turn chickens and cows existences into support to grow protein and nothing else does remind me of the spider.
We do exactly that.
You can use a framework of moral relativism where intelligent spiders have no need to adhere to human-centric rules, and all, but I prefer the moral absolutism that no one who can understand I don't want to be eaten is morally permitted to eat me.
We just draw a line saying: this is ok, this is not, arbitrarily. Nobody, nothing, wants to suffer. That's one of the rare things life universally agrees on.
There is no need for words to express that.
And I think it's ok to do so, but if we can eat whales, octopus, and take cows and chickens and make their existence hell until we consume them, labeling a spider as "evil" because it likes eating humans is far fetched.
If the giant spiders were unintelligent, they'd not be moral actors, and then eating people might be a bad thing, but it wouldn't be a morally bad (evil) thing.
If their prey weren't intelligent, my moral framework doesn't (currently) include an absolute prohibition on killing and eating animals, so that would be morally acceptable.
But because both the spider and their prey were intelligent, my rules kick in and it is immoral for the spiders to eat people, or vice versa.
(Now, there may be a loophole in that killing people for the purposes of eating them is always unacceptable, but there are circumstances where it is at least forgivable to kill [eg, self defense], and also circumstances where it is likewise acceptable to eat already dead intelligent creatures, but you have to be careful not to create a moral hazard where the killing is done on a pretext.)
I think the "evil" concept is baked into the themes of the books. While men are capable of evil, Shelob, Morgoth, Sauron etc are basically the embodiment of sin and incapable of good. So the only way you can say they aren't evil is if you ignore the prose and judge them by their actions against the worst humanity can accomplish.
> Intelligent spiders prevent expansion into Mirkwood.
Doesn't sound like targeting non-aggressive travelers.
You may have made some assumptions based on it, but those assumptions were wrong.
Furthermore, "preventing expansion" does not necessarily imply morally acceptable self defense.
Should be easy to find a quote then.
You and I are also very much the descendant of mass murderers that waged wars, raped and tortured.
I don't consider myself evil, but because of this, I just think the spider is acting like a spider.
I don't see that being evil either.
If you have a problem with that, feel free to headcanon it away. I don't care. But in terms of understanding the world of JRR Tolkien at least as written, they're evil. Not just misunderstood, but actively in the service of the outright destruction of the world, lacking only the agency to do so.