The emacs GUI inside a terminal window - invoked w/ xterm-mouse-mode - is still rather minimal. I'm thinking more about emacs-gtk or Aquamacs. You could argue that the GUI gives you access to more system capabilities in a straightforward way - buttons/controls v keybindings - but this isn't a dealbreaker for me.
As long as I have a readily available reference for keybindings, that's good enough for me.
There’s just no way that the GUI adds bloat in any meaningful sense; it’s the same program either way.
Emacs keybindings are complicated enough that I'd rather keep the ability to click a button available at all times even if I don't use it regularly - see my prior comment re BBEdit.
Such is life that I have some physical issues with my hands that make a purely keyboard driven interface occasionally uncomfortable. The chorded keystrokes in Vim were not satisfying to me, so I went in an emacs direction ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
When I started building out my init.el, it became apparent that I needed an escape hatch from time to time - this is it.