Austin Gave Poor Families a Basic Income. It Changed Their Lives
vice.com
vice.com
This suggests that the money flows directly to landlords. If you give this to everyone, rents will rise by about $1,000/month. I'd recommend against policies like this. Australia has a lot of policies that push money into the housing market and it just means that sooner or later nobody can afford a house.
In a practical sense, the only way for people to get better lives is to work better jobs. If people get more money, they just fight to change the distribution of presently available stuff. To cause sustainable improvements, people need to have the skills, knowhow and opportunity to produce more/higher quality stuff.
Now do inflation and people who already have skills and are forced to work multiple jobs to afford to live somewhere to do the first job, i.e., NHS workers in the UK. And yet we have council housing here, but the waiting lists are long, and we have plenty of unoccupied and unused properties under private ownership. These are complex issues and it starts with property being treated as an "investment" or a revenue stream rather than what it is—shelter.
I've been advocating deregulating nuclear power and looking for cheap energy that way for a long time. Possibly renewables has also gotten cheap enough to cover the gap, although realistically it has so much political support the fact that it hasn't suggests it is uneconomic. China just built lots of coal plants. Life has been on the up-and-up for the average Chinese worker. Weird how that works out.
Part of helping people get good jobs involves allowing capitalists to build power stations. Handing out $1,000 checks to random families is unlikely to help with that.
[0] https://ourworldindata.org/energy/country/united-kingdom#per...
Ultimately though there are shortages of lots of things, housing and jobs being but two of them.
In an ideal world, an increase in rent would increase the value of housing, which would make building housing more valuable and thus more houses eould be built, thus reducing the cost of housing, thus balancing the equation. Land ownership, zoning, and the cost of commuting to low-paid jobs works against that.
One could argue that the homeless of say california move to the unoccupied housing of say detroit, but that presumes there are jobs in detriot.
In reality of course there are sufficient resources (food, housing etc) for everyone. But distributing that for the common good, rather than individual gain is a sticky problem.
If you pay for the $1k via progressive taxation, then it will make the lives of people at the low end a bit better, at the cost of making high end a bit worse.
The only way to make everyone’s lives better is to increase supply in the supply and demand equation, we get that via improved productivity, which happens via better jobs where your time is worth more.
But I agree with your (unstated) point, basic income also needs tighter limits imposed on rent seeking behaviour. But I reckon we need tighter limits on rent seeking behaviour anyway.
This is a classic pincer manoeuvre in class warfare, where the top of the pyramid brings in a policy that extracts X from the middle class, then divvies it up at at a 10%-90% split between the lower and upper class. The majority of the benefit goes to the landlords. It is a cynical policy.
The actual policy that is good for everyone is to generate more wealth so that more of the lower class moves into the middle class. That would be policies that increase the housing stock, removal of policies that unduly favour rent seeking, or the classic land tax that nobody wealthy wants to talk about. We've been at this for centuries - redistribution is not the way to set people up for success. Giving them opportunities to work hard on valuable things is.
UBI removes place dependencies that reduce people's abilities to move, so it can also have a down ward tendency on average rent.
UBI will be a win for landlords with reasonably priced rents in locations with fewer jobs, but it shouldn't enable exorbitant increases elsewhere.
Rent is a function mostly of supply. Fix that and you fix rent UBI or no.
Taking money out of the pockets of taxpayers and handing it over to those too lazy to work, additionally disincentivizing them to work, is one of the worst violations of public fairness of our times.
There is zero control over how the money is spent, and we witnessed many cases of people perceiving it with no right to, universal income harvesting, corruption, and so on.
At least regulate how the money is spent and double, triple check the requests to perceive universal income.