1. US flagged and owned 2. US crewed 3. US built.
I genuinely agree with the first two points. Most container ships sail under flags of convenience (so that they can minimize regulations in terms of conduct/the environment/etc) and with crews from developing nations that they abuse and treat as indentured servants.
Do you want to allow US domestic shipping to be done by entities over which the US has negligible regulatory control? I don’t!
The third is intended (along with the other 2) to ensure that the US maintains strategically important maritime capabilities, to retain the ability to build and crew a merchant marine. Personally I think this is a less compelling case than the regulation case, but I don’t think it’s totally without merit.
I think the idea that this is responsible for the high cost of goods in Hawaii and Puerto Rico is basically not credible, because it doesn’t prevent those ports being included in import sailings. You could make a case that it makes those places less competitive as manufacturers of goods for export to the rest of the US, but if you think that the jones act is the major reason Hawaii isn’t a manufacturing hub… idk what to tell you.
I think the other reality is that even if you like (1) and (2) but not (3) it’s hard to break it apart because the jones act unites concerns over the ability to regulate with concerns over strategic readiness, which creates a coalition to maintain it that would potentially break otherwise.
> Now imagine a future without the Jones Act, where Chinese-flagged vessels all controlled, in whole or in part, by the Chinese Communist Party—were able to freely dock at our domestic ports, cruise our coastlines, and travel up and down our inland waterways. From the St. Lawrence Seaway in the Great Lakes right through our heartland on the Mississippi River, the Chinese Communist Party would have virtually unrestricted access to essential American economic arteries. That access would position our adversaries to do far greater damage to American infrastructure than the pipeline hackers ever imagined.
> Moreover, the American merchant marine and civilian shipping industry would be virtually eliminated by state-subsidized Chinese vessels, just like our manufacturing and industrial base were severely damaged by predatory Chinese practices over the past two decades. And critically, the reserve of merchant mariners and civilian cargo ships we require in the event of conflict would be significantly eroded.
Which is dumb. You could still repeal the Jones Act and require the ships to be US flagged or crewed. Or restrict it to countries that have signed security/trade deals with the US.
Even still, were war declared, a Chinese grain barge in Missouri isn't going to pose much of a threat. Most likely it would be commandeered by the US anyway!
I understand the (theoretical) uses during a peer/near-peer war, but even outside of the (IMO) poor economic implications, I think it can be extremely detrimental to something like emergency response times. Historically the government has been forced to issue temporary waivers during natural disasters but that delay in response time could be life-changing.
> Even still, were war declared, a Chinese grain barge in Missouri isn't going to pose much of a threat. Most likely it would be commandeered by the US anyway!
No, your idea is dumb. If war is declared, are the Chinese going to let the US use its shipyards?
The 90s called, and it wants its always-smooth-sailing free trade fantasies back.
But even if the Mississippi was covered in Chinese manufactured and owned ships, if war were to break out, we would just seize the ships. There would not be a huge impact to our infrastructure.
The only real vulnerability would be deep-water domestic transport - places like Guam and Hawaii. But the irony is the Jones Act has made these places more reliant on Chinese shipping because domestic transit options are so stinking expensive.
Why would that be true? To work in the US you still need to (mostly) have legitimate papers. We don't require every truck or train in the US to only be driven by US citizens. It's weird to think that a barge going up and down the Mississippi would be held to a different standard.
One thing people don't realize about the Jones Act is that it requires 75% of crews to be American citizens. The law dates back to a time when it was just as much about being anti-immigrant as it was protectionist.
There may be elements of the Mississippi River Boat job which make using foreign crews completely impractical - like, maybe it can't be done without at least some of them going ashore? I'm pretty sure there aren't immigration agents at every river port!) - so maybe it's not a concern. I don't know anywhere near enough about the subject to make confident assertions about that.
> 75% of crews to be American citizens
I didn't know that, either! Thanks.
Requiring that these vessels adhere to American laws is exactly the intent of requiring them to be American flagged and crewed.
I would agree with you that it's probably outdates that crewing has to be predominantly citizens and otherwise LPRs and it probably makes sense to open this up to legitimate immigrant labor too. But I'd argue that's an adjustment to the Jones Act vs a repeal of it.
I think it's worth bearing in mind that we're responding to an article by the Cato Institute. Their interest is in stripping away regulations that put limits on big businesses. They are primarily funded by the Koch Family, whose companies spend _huge_ sums on domestic shipping in particular (think about the volume that Georgia-Pacific moves around). Of course they're in favor of reducing regulations that limit domestic shipping: they'd probably love to turn around and use a Liberia-flagged, Filipino crewed ship to move domestic shipments. It doesn't make their arguments _inherently_ valid, but there is an obvious self-serving motive.
In any world where China and the US are shooting at each other, Japan and South Korea are getting shot at too. They have the severe drawback of being in adversary's backyard, not an ocean away.
Not to say there aren't problems with US shipbuilding that need to be fixed (IIRC, unlike South Korea and Japan, all the suppliers and subcontractors are too geographically dispersed to be globally competitive), but repealing the Jones Act won't help with that.
> But even if the Mississippi was covered in Chinese manufactured and owned ships, if war were to break out, we would just seize the ships. There would not be a huge impact to our infrastructure.
That's assuming all the US needs in a war are its existing stock of ships with no need for replenishment, but that's almost certainly not true.
Also, China's not dumb. What if the conflict is timed so that most of those ships are in no position to be seized? Or scuttled right as the conflict starts?
But how about let's go all the way, and outsource military manufacturing the the China and Russia. What could go wrong? There's no such thing as a back door.
For merchant vessels, I think we'd have to get by with what was already in the market before the war; or as the sibling pointed out, get by with orders built by other Asian countries. Commandeering merchant vessels owned / flagged by the other side of a war is pretty common. And while fleets typically go through a regular replacement regime, you can always extend things a bit, unless there's a lot of sinking of the merchant fleet; depends on the details of the war.