1. Smaller vehicles have tighter emissions requirements and those requirements increase every year. So manufacturers of ICE vehicles have tended towards larger and larger vehicles year after year.
2. In the wake of Japanese auto manufacturers eating US manufacturer's lunch in the US we banned entire swaths of vehicles (minitrucks, microvans, kei cars). Because of this, in practice vehicles below a certain size that are produced by some of our main non-domestic (and maybe also domestic but I'm not sure) auto manufacturers (toyota, honda, mazda, nissan, subaru, etc) are illegal in the US unless they are a model that is 25 years old.
So we've made it impractical or even in some cases impossible to even build, sell, and market smaller but just as practical vehicles. If we fix that issue first, I imagine the market will eventually trend back towards smaller, cheaper, practical, and more efficient vehicles.
I think this ship has sailed and there's no coming down in vehicle sizes in US any time soon.
> Starting from inclusivity arguments centered around smaller cars not being able to fit "people of all sizes"
Idk. I don't think there's substantially different cabin sizes past a certain point. The space any given seat has in an escalade or F-150 really isn't that different to the space a significantly smaller RAV4 has. And even between say a RAV4 and a camry the amount of space isn't massively different (however the rav does have more space).
This isn't to say that you should be banning normal sized vehicles but there really should be some type of disincentive for 4000+ lb vehicles and maybe an incentive for ultralight vehicles as well.
Those are safety requirement issues. That's why classics get an exemption. You can't domestically manufacturer simular vehicles because they wouldn't meet the standards either.
We basically set the laws such that their niche wasn't viable despite being perfectly safe.
I think there's some background missing here on a definition and the restrictions of those classes.
Slap taxes above a certain weight, and you will see manufacturers drop the weight to right below the threshold faster than you can blink.
The point is, you're welcome to shop for non-CA items, if they're legal in your region.