There are plenty of counter examples to this (and also pretty unclear what is meant by "natural")
Lead is natural. Mercury is natural.
There are plenty of counter examples to this (and also pretty unclear what is meant by "natural")
Lead is natural. Mercury is natural.
Humans have been naturally digging these things up and refining them since at least the Roman Empire [1] in the west and the earliest Chinese Dynasties in the East [2].
[1] https://sites.dartmouth.edu/toxmetal/more-metals/lead-versat...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mausoleum_of_the_First_Qin_Emp...
"Don’t dump chemicals in water or on land" is a perfectly logical and defensible statement.
See how that works?
Real productive mode of conversation, huh.
https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2022-05-18/heres-w...
classic bad-faith interpretation, using the classic bad-faith slogan. No, you’re not “just trying to understand” anything, and GP is absolutely correct about that.
We are not dying for content here without your “hurr durr don’t you know water is a chemical posts, and we generally try to maintain a higher level of discourse here. Maybe try Reddit instead.
Please see the site rules about using the most generous possible interpretation of a comment, and if you actually have something to contribute then maybe try again.
I'm being plenty charitable in assuming you're arguing in good faith, at first glance your comment comes off as anti-intellectual value signalling, which will never ever solve anything. Ever.
But this is HN, so I'm going to assume you've simply misunderstood the concern, as anti intellectualism has no place here.
Okay, no more fertilizer on the crops then. Enjoy the famine.
Words have different meanings in different contexts. Pretending that "chemicals" can only ever be used to refer to all material substances equally is just intentionally trying to sabotage productive discussion.
Well define it then.
Nobody is complaing that there might be an alternative definition of chemical.
The complaint is that you're not using any widely known definition of "chemical" and not providing your own definition.
You can shut everyone up by just defining how you are using the word. I doubt you will since i think you are lying about there existing some other definition that makes sense in the context you are arguing, and you lack the knowledge/ability to make up your own definition that would fit your argument.
Now would you like to discuss which "substances produced by chemical processes" are likely to be the most impactful upon the environment, or would you like to continue quibbling over semantics?
chemical [ kem-i-kuhl ]SHOW IPA
noun
a substance produced by or used in a chemical process.
chemicals, Slang. narcotic or mind-altering drugs or substances.
adjective
of, used in, produced by, or concerned with chemistry or chemicals: a chemical formula; chemical agents.
used in chemical warfare: chemical weapons.
> "It’s pretty simple, don’t dump chemicals in water or on land period."
Then i still maintain anyone using that definition of chemical in the context of that statement is an utter idiot.
> Now would you like to discuss which "substances produced by chemical processes" are likely to be the most impactful upon the environment
Why? There is already a government department tasked with that, that can probably do a better job then you or i could.
If you're trying to argue that the status quo is fine and we shouldn't change anything, then you have a weird way of doing so.