It's amazing how much they have to work around things that would incriminate or sway a jury (such as cutting out anything that might reveal priors), and this would be something more.
It's amazing how much they have to work around things that would incriminate or sway a jury (such as cutting out anything that might reveal priors), and this would be something more.
Isn't this necessary especially in larger cases where it's necessary to get one suspect to roll over on another?
As long as defense attorneys are involved, what is the harm in this?
There's the harm.
If preventing cops from lying results in fewer trials going to court for violent crime, then I'd be curious to compare the two figures.
I'm anxious about having fewer tools to investigate and prosecute. We used to have a 70% homicide clearance rate, but that's dropped to just 50% [1]. This feels like we'd be further trying our hands.
[1] https://thehill.com/homenews/3878472-nearly-half-of-us-murde...
MOST of them are guilty, so killing ALL of them is OK! Wouldn't want to let off the guilty ones.
The smart cops cut out all of this by simply killing the unarmed suspect before pronouncing the 'p' in 'stop'.
"Hell no" seems like the obvious answer, but you seem to disagree?
But we're supposed to presume "innocent until proven guilty". A suspect is only accused, not convicted.
The whole point here is that the person at this stage is presumed innocent.
Good point, suspects have a right to an attorney and the right to remain silent. But much of the successful lying probably happens when an attorney isn't present. For example "look, we can wait for your lawyer to get here, but this is looking really bad for you. We just arrested your buddy and once he sings we'll just throw the book at you. If you give your side of the story first, you get the better deal."
A suspect without a lawyer might waive the right to counsel/silence and incriminate himself. Of course, he would be guilty, so it's not entirely clear this is a bad thing (unless he is falsely admitting guilt, which does occasionally happen).
There are multiple countries where it's not allowed, so it's definitely not necessary.
>As long as defense attorneys are involved, what is the harm in this?
Generally the cops will try as hard as they think they can get away with to keep your attorney away. This article is about someone who immediately asked if he should have an attorney, was told he didn't need one, and when one showed up anyways, he wasn't even allowed to know there was someone hired to represent him.
The harm is that juries and judges really love signed confessions and cops love to pressure for one. The Reid Technique's entire goal is to take someone from saying "no, I didn't do it" to "okay, I'll sign that I did it". Ted Bradford had an alibi and a recanted confession that confessed things that obviously didn't match the facts of the case, and the confession was enough even when he finally had an attorney. It was enough that:
>Despite the exonerating DNA evidence and the fact that Ted had already served his entire sentence for the crime, Yakima County prosecutors chose to charge Ted with the same sexual assault once again, offering his initial false statement in 1996 as the evidence against him.
Not to mention that defense attorneys are usually overworked, working for free and you generally get what you pay for.
(One of the strange side-effects of mandatory sentencing is removing plea deals because if they HAVE to charge you with X, and guilty or plead on X is Y years in jail, then there is no reason not to go to a jury trial, because the worst case is you get Y years anyway, which you get when you plea out.)
If criminals really were organized and forced everything to jury trials, the United States would collapse.
And the “defense attorneys” are going to be overworked underpaid public defenders while the prosecutors have what amounts to an unlimited budget
I understand how impossibly hard that could be in the moment, but never never go quietly into that dark night.
Unless, of course, you're guilty and you know it, then clap your hands on anything that reduces what you have to suffer for it, I guess.
How about because defense attorneys are very expensive?
The problem is that--so far--we don't have a good way to allow the acceptable kinds while also prohibiting the terrible kinds.
Imagine the police give an overwhelming list of false/non-existent evidence and testimony, so that the average (innocent) person would assume they're being deliberately framed by some power they are unable to fight, and that the only way to protect themselves and their loved ones is to buckle under.
Another example would be where police lie/deliberately-mislead a suspect about the consequences of a confession.