[0] https://www2.tulane.edu/~sanelson/Natural_Disasters/impacts....
[0] https://www2.tulane.edu/~sanelson/Natural_Disasters/impacts....
I guess the author ran the 54t / 100 calc and came up with 0.45 instead of 0.54 ... a simple typo.
The key point is most of the natural stuff doesn't hang around up there.
Top end (10^9 Kg) of the range we get about 2750t per day natural origin. And at 1% for Aluminium that's 27.5t per day. That number is not far off the 29t estimated daily burn for the full Starlink v2 constellation they quote.
Also:
I notice that the Lodders article focussed specifically on Aluminium as it had been proposed as a method for geoengineering albedo.
There are other metals in the natural origin material, and I don't see why we should exclude those from affecting the Van Allen belts - is it only Aluminium that's bad?
Comparing the Starlink burn to the Van Allen material mass seems irrelevant when there's perhaps a few hundred tonnes per day of naturally arriving metals around too.
It's not obvious to me this topic can be waved away as not an issue though.
Why you think so?