And it's written from the viewpoint of pro-density. Read the linked papers there, the best results of density increases are either extremely indirect ("migration chains") or insignificant (no sale price decreases, and single-digit percentage one-time decreases in rent).
I'm writing an analysis of all densifications in the US and Canada. So far, I have not found a _single_ example of density increases leading to even slowing down of sale prices. Never mind their reduction.
On the other hand, they ALWAYS lead to worsening commutes and shrinking square footage per capita.
Mense (2023) showed a 1% yearly increase in housing supply in Germany results in an average local municipality rent to fall by 0.2%.
Asquith et al. (2023) found in NYC, the average new building lowers nearby rents within 250 meters of the new building by 5% to 7% relative to the trend rent growth otherwise would have followed.
Li (2022), looked at new market rate buildings of 7+ stories and found that for every 10% increase to the housing stock that new high rises add within a 500-ft ring, residential rents for the buildings within that ring decrease by 1 percent.
Pennington (2021) found rents within 500 meters of a new project fell by 1.2 to 2.3% in San Francisco.
I have not read this one yet. Sounds suspicious, though.
The rest are basically what I told: one-time single-digit percentage decreases in rents. This one is also funny:
> Asquith et al. (2023) found in NYC, the average new building lowers nearby rents within 250 meters of the new building by 5% to 7% relative to the trend rent growth otherwise would have followed.
Rents still _increased_, but slightly slower.
Why would one expect a single increase in supply of available housing units to cause more than a one-time decrease in rent?
> Rents still _increased_, but slightly slower.
I'm not entirely sure why you find this funny. It finds adding housing units reduces surrounding future rents. If you find it funny it didn't lower rent in absolute terms for some reason, extrapolate what would happen to the rent of an place within 250 meters of 20 new buildings.
Read it. Oh wow. That's a fucking propaganda piece with shoddy statistics.
They basically found a statistical anomaly in the data, with the one- and two- bedroom apartments rents showing no significant difference from the historical trend. And to exaggerate the trend, they used an overfitted exponential model.
And in both cases, there were NO price decreases. Rents continued to grow, outpacing the inflation.
Also, yes also agree about more jobs and opportunities more distributed across the land. That sounds good.
I think about my position as favoring walkable dense metros in the more organic manner - people like people - we WANT to be close to one another. And the infrastructure to make that possible, comfortable, affordable, and sustainable.. is great!
The exchange of ideas and tolerance leading to innovation, is a function of dense metros. Is that not just fundamentally...true?
Governments are human organizations, and it's not a surprise that some organizations are better ran than other.
That said, yes for sure there's much suck about the filth, obliviousness, and inconsideration of "other people". I like people, but I do not live on top of people. I want the ability to walk or bike to my stimulus. And then retreat back to solitude.
Completely get you! In simple terms, I just think it has to occur silly to people, that 8 billion humans are gonna have their 2 acres of land and that that is somehow _actually_ ideal beyond "I want what I want the way I want it". Quite literally the concept of Civilization is honoring a WE more than an I.
And you’re entitled to not want to live in a dense urban environment, but you might need to open your mind to the idea that not everyone feels the way you do.
You're entitled to move away from a toxic river that catches fire. But you might need to open your mind to the idea that not everyone feels the way you do. Perhaps some people like to work at the factory that produces the toxic slime.
Urban density is pollution. Its effects are not limited to cities.
By making it easier for companies to open offices in dense urban cores, it ensures that smaller cities are starved of jobs and die. So people are forced to move to ever-densifying areas, driving up the price. This in turn makes it even easier for companies to hire people living near dense urban cores.
Rinse, wash, repeat.
Do you think suburbia is an efficient and effective use of land?
Oh, absolutely. It's more efficient for companies to hire workforce in dense cities and offload the externalities (increasing cost of living) onto the public.
Just like with pollution: if you dump toxic sludge into rivers, your factory can make widgets cheaper, than a factory that has to take care of its waste.
> Do you think suburbia is an efficient and effective use of land?
I don't think _efficiency_ should be the reason for cities. A polluting factory is also more efficient than a clean factory. Yet we somehow don't appreciate that efficiency anymore.
Moreover, the amount of urban areas is around 2% of the total land area in the US. De-aggregating the cities will only result in its increase by maybe 20%.
This is simply not the case. People living in dense walkable urban areas produce far less pollution than those living in the suburbs who need to drive much more and require far more infrastructure per household.
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/its-not-just-cities-subur...
Switching from gas cars to EVs and downsizing from barn-sized SUVs to medium-sized cars will solve the emissions issues.
Moreover, extrapolating the self-driving vehicles trend a bit, mild automated car-pooling will completely negate emissions advantage of EVERY other intracity public transit method.
Remote Work You need pervasive remote jobs to move any meaningful number of people away from the companies that presently fund their lifestyle.
Government and Desirability
Flyover states are run by gross people whose theories on how our country ought to be run that are misaligned with the people you wish would move there. This is going to cause in not many years a crisis situation with doctors choosing to move to more desirable locations and small cities lack a lot of the amenities and interest of living in the big city. People are already choosing not to live there despite decrease costs. Small cities are BORING.
The temptation is to only build government housing for the poor, but that’s a well known recipe for failure. The US has instead shifted to government spreading out poor population via subsidies but that’s doesn’t fix any of the core issues.
This only works as long as rural people keep having lots of kids to feed into the city, but that isn’t really happening anymore either.
It's not because of density - it's because people with options other than raising children tend to pick them since kids require a lot of effort.
SF and LA could easily be several times more dense than they currently are; that kind of increase would see the capacity of the entire state grow by double-digit percentages.
So now I've gotta ask you: if cities suck for population growth, then where would those double-digit population gains come from? It's not rural America, that's for sure.
[0] https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/popest/2...
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/67/wr/mm6745a9.htm https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2017/08/rural-america...
Based on actual data urban individuals (80% of the pop) aren't dependent upon rurals (20% of the pop) having babies because by the numbers most of the native born sons and daughters are born in urban and suburban areas. In fact both are dependent upon immigration to maintain the same level of population.