Perhaps not prohibited. But we could make it so they lose all IP rights.
Copyright is intended to promote the creation and distribution of new works. It is not a natural human right, like ownership of your physical things.
Perhaps not prohibited. But we could make it so they lose all IP rights.
Copyright is intended to promote the creation and distribution of new works. It is not a natural human right, like ownership of your physical things.
I'm not sure how that would work. Suppose I make two draft comics of my original character ExampleMan. One features a dark brooding morally ambiguous anti-hero, and the other is a wholesome family character.
Are you saying if I destroy one draft and publish the other, the character comes partially or wholly into the public domain? Or that I am prohibited from claiming the time and money used to make one of the drafts as the legitimate business expense?
Would same logic also apply to a patents of a company that creates 10 different prototype engine designs, and decides to only bring one of them to market?
However, for a really big project, there's a "salvage value" or "scrap value." It's not zero.
If all the prototypes were for the same patent, there's no issue.
For the draft comics, I think you could pretty well argue those are part of the same work. And I'd be okay excluding projects under a certain size from the rule.
If you then destroy your original work or refuse to let other people use it on reasonable terms, you can't sue people for copyright infringement when they use it.
> Would same logic also apply to a patents of a company that creates 10 different prototype engine designs, and decides to only bring one of them to market?
I think you shouldn't be able to use patent protection unless you also make your design available on the market for a reasonable fee.
If they're actually destroying all copies as claimed, then IP rights is irrelevant.
Not if someone managed to make a copy of the movie.
And I don't think you should be able to use copyright protection unless you register a copy with a central authority. Just like how patents work.
If you look at anthropology pre-modern humans were extremely family/tribe oriented. Resources were generally the property of the tribe as a whole. I don't think that the modern understanding of personal property would translate well to someone from such a culture, which makes me sceptical of the idea that personal property is an innate element of human nature.