Realistically I think the existing criminal justice system would be hard put to claim a wrongful conviction rate lower than that, so... I'm not sure this argument cuts the way you want it to. If you have a 99% accurate test of guilt, that seems like more than enough probable cause to continue investigating, and probably good enough to convict with just a little extra corroboration.
While there's a privacy argument to be made, I really don't think you're going to get very far arguing that this is going to cause quality problems. Frankly I think it's likely to help with reducing false imprisonment (i.e. by fingering the right suspect earlier, before the wrong one ends up in court).