> the moment we fell off the streak, it broke completely
This sounds strange to me. I used the streak method for several physical activities. At first I was worried I would not keep it up, so it was very important to not miss any single day. But after 100 days? A miss does nothing. I have proof I can keep it up, and that motivates me to continue. Besides, life happens, it's impossible to _never_ miss a day of anything.
The first weeks are harder, but after that, I look more for a moving average. If I have 95 of the last 100 days, I'm doing great.