I guess I'm not thinking about an all-tech shop (like a web startup) so much as a business that needs a specialized dev and has no one technical enough to judge them on board.
Be real. That place is competing for employees with folks who aren't playing games.
"Come work for us, we're clueless" isn't a selling point.
> The up-shot is you would start working the next day at your 'monopoly rate', versus going through rounds and rounds of interviews at all sorts of other companies.
Why do you think that those are the only alternatives?
The responses you're getting are from the point of view of a tech-based company. Because your approach has no advantage for the top-notch dev, who at the moment is in a white-hot market and able to write their own ticket at a company that IS able to judge their ability and isn't going to try to get some cheap work out of them.
★ The "work for less" argument sounds like a weasel game. If you're playing weasel games before I've even started working for you, what are the odds that you'll continue playing games? Pretty high, I'd say.
★ $100/hour for an SAP consultant or a Hadoop expert? Give me a break - that's the rate for a reasonable dev who can build a system themselves.
★ There's usually not a lot of opportunity cost for decent developers when interviewing, since they'll already be employed or doing lots of contract work (and turning more away). A couple of phone calls or emails, or an application or two is usually all it takes.
So... remind me why I should come work for your hypothetical company again?