The Citizen app works (afaik) by drumming up fear of crime, and therefore emotionally addicting people. According to a Fast Company article (that everyone should read), Citizen has staff adding crime reports to feeds that are peaceful.
But they specialize in crime and have a profit motive. Why would neighbors be drumming up fear of crime?
It's incredibly tiresome.
For this specific case, no of course I can't be sure, I don't know the specific neighbors.
It's not just middle schoolers. Our primate ancestors love to socialize; we've been doing it for seven million years. That's what social media sells. It's certainly not utilitarianism!
It all goes back to who the mods are, in this case "nextdoor" did not ban him it was local mods.
They get a little fiefdom and then ban dissent in their area, OP just pissed off one of the local "big fish".
No moderation is highly preferable to me if the alternative is orwellian censorship
No moderation, outside specific situations, is unusable.
Moderation in the classical sense, where spam/off topic content is removed?
or
"Moderation": Consensus manipulation, speech/thought policing, censorship of opposing/controversial ideas, etc?
Because in practice "Moderation" is what you get (and what they spend most of their time doing), but they sell you on the above by fear mongering about spam.
I want to hear from all sorts of people, and I want free expression. But I don't want to spend time with people who behave badly - people shouting, people saying offensive things, people being rude, etc. Humanity universally has manners and social norms for a reason, to enable us to interact.
Public forums are vulnerable to people coming in and behaving badly; we need moderators to keep the place civil without suppressing free expression.