This makes takedown mills and fake take downs economically unfeasible and is reasonable for claimants in that it awards some money for dealing with fraudulent and mistaken claims.
This makes takedown mills and fake take downs economically unfeasible and is reasonable for claimants in that it awards some money for dealing with fraudulent and mistaken claims.
To perform a crackdown on those 7 million listings, you're proposing that Disney would need to make a $700 million dollar deposit with Etsy and wait for hopefully most of it to trickle back in. If the infringer is somewhere on the other side of the globe that Disney can't easily reach legally, they can't get their deposit back until they spend thousands filing a federal lawsuit that'll go unanswered, so the deposit is more than forfeit in many of these cases. That's for a single company to defend a single franchise on a single website.
I don't think this is a "simple" solution.
Good, don't make the claim. Maybe multi-billion dollar companies shouldn't be enforcing copyright in such a draconian way in the first place.
First, let's not use IP here. Let's be specific and say copyright since that is what DMCA covers.
> Etsy.com
This is an awful example as etsy would be the company that the DMCA takedown would be against. Etsy certainly is worth suing or profiting from selling unlicensed goods.
> $700 million dollar deposit
The amount of the deposit you use is the high end of the range. Even so, you didn't account that each deposit covers up to 100 URLs, so the deposit would be $70M which I think the mouse can afford, easily.
> they can't get their deposit back until they spend thousands filing a federal lawsuit that'll go unanswered,
The deposit would go back if the takedown does not get a counterclaim. Legitimate claims would result in the deposit being returned. Not every claim will have a counterclaim. If there is a counterclaim, the next step is a Federal lawsuit anyway. And if they don't answer you get a default judgement that can be collected in many countries around the world, and even on contingency.
> I don't think this is a "simple" solution.
You gave very little consideration to the people that are badly affected by fake counterclaims, and are assuming that every actor is a bad faith factory.
Etsy is a marketplace that connects independent buyers and sellers, like eBay but only for handmade and vintage goods. Every item on their site is listed, sold and shipped by a third party. Every listing image and description is "user generated content". They are a service provider with no liability for copyright infringement on their platform so long as they follow the DMCA process.
Like any major UGC host, they have an IP reporting portal for companies like Disney to make large-scale sweeps of the whole marketplace for infringing listings and file complaints en masse. They do so somewhat regularly. I remember all the noise when they issued mass claims against all the "Baby Yoda" merchandise on Etsy.
Etsy is not a major "UGC" host, they are a marketplace taking a cut of sales for product.
It's not necessary to register a work with the US Copyright Office to have copyright protection, but registration is necessary to file an infringement claim in court.
Registering takes time and money, and the registration database is public. Simply requiring a URL that points to the work's registration as part of the DMCA notice should take care of the problem.
You can register post-infringement and sue anyway.
> Simply requiring a URL that points to the work's registration as part of the DMCA notice should take care of the problem.
I don't think an amateur photographer should have to pay a registration fee on every photo.
Never said otherwise. But if the copyright holder is serious about stopping the infringement, then registration will have to be done if the infringer files a counterclaim, in order to go to the next step.
> I don't think an amateur photographer should have to pay a registration fee on every photo.
They wouldn't, just the ones that are infringed.