The economies of scale that put food on your table and mine and clothe our kids - for all the horrors - will not be replaced by artisans doing small batch t-shirts from yard-grown cotton using hand made tools.
The economies of scale that put food on your table and mine and clothe our kids - for all the horrors - will not be replaced by artisans doing small batch t-shirts from yard-grown cotton using hand made tools.
That isn't what I'm talking about. There is a lot between that and transporting everything multiple times across the globe just for the sake of making it as large scale as possible. What is the gain after you can reliably feed a few looms?
There are no better tools by the way. It's people sitting behind sewing machines, just on the other side of the planet.
I think my argument was mostly like - don’t throw out the baby with the bath water; economies of scale are a real thing that brings us real benefits, and that should go in the scale too.
I don't think obfuscating "there is a dropoff point in size where economies of scale stop being better for humanity and start getting worse" with "we must switch to artisinal backyard t-shirt making" is really steelmanning here.
The sheer size and scale of the economy we live in, and it's benefits, is so big that people tend to make sweeping pronouncements without really understanding their impact.
The point about industrially produced cotton is exactly right: people pick some niche thing they view as "wasteful" and vastly over estimate it's importance or impact.