James Siminoff: I would create a fully self contained incubator
jamessiminoff.com
jamessiminoff.com
Even if investors did stop investing, it wouldn't kill us. At the last Demo Day, 4 of the companies presenting were already profitable. (All 4 have had offers of investment, incidentally.) At the next Demo Day the ratio of profitable companies will be even higher.
As for his alternative suggestion, among other problems, it wouldn't give startups any more runway. There's no reason to suppose that if we got into the real estate business, we could offer space to startups any cheaper than they can get it on the open market.
As an aside, I love the author Jamie Siminoff, I enjoy our product brainstorming sessions, and think his company Phonetag is awesome, but I think this article is a bit empty. I wonder if companies would be as hungry to succeed if they had guaranteed place to stay in a hotel that resembled a 24 hour lan party? Probably not.
I should probably write a follow up about how I would envision the "24 hour party". For example for sure you would not be gauranteed to stay, the ability to stay would be based on how the company and team are working. So in essence every week or 2 would be viewed as an additional round. However with this cost basis unlike others you could keep a company going a lot longer if you believed traction would come.
Nahhh.
It wouldn't have fit my company, for example. We have baggage...family, dog, lives outside of our company, etc. I kinda doubt several of the most successful YC companies would have signed on at all for such an intense sort of experience.
Beyond the basic expenses of buying a hotel in the valley (I think the cost is being underestimated, even in this economic climate), the expenses of operating it are going to be very high, even without staffing it as a hotel. It's obviously a mandatory expense, and everyone needs somewhere to live, but you're not going to save a huge amount of money over individuals placing themselves in their own apartment or house. And, more importantly you're going to self-select out of being able to fund any company that doesn't exactly fit the stereotype: Fresh out of college, no family, not from the area and thus not already settled somewhere in the valley, not needing to have a presence outside of the valley for business reasons, etc.
This is one of those things that sounds cool, but I think it takes the simple, and obviously successful, kernel of YC and adds a non-essential boondoggle that doesn't actually improve on the model.
I believe the solution to the "what happens after" shouldn't be "make sure the founders never have to think about after by infantilizing them and making sure they never have to think about necessities", but instead should be "make sure the founders are well-prepared for after". After is going to come eventually, if the company is to be a success.
But the idea that you can put something out there on the cheap, get traction and become profitable is very much alive.
You can run a startup for two years for less than the cost of grad school. If anything, the YC model is more alive than ever. The labels should be worrying, not the talent.
I got as far as:
Google = Beatles
Myspace = Monsters of Metal
37Signals = Led Zeppelin
#silly I know.
First of all, my belief was that PG graduated from five different colleges around the world because he liked being around smart young people, and to continue to be in a college-like atmosphere of optimistic young people without going to school in the U.S. and Europe for yet another degree, he started YCombinator, where he convinces smart young people to come to him, which is a much more efficient way of being around smart young people.
Another way I've thought about it was that PG was like a manager of boy bands of 2-4 young people, who try to entertain fellow college men instead of young girls (and later on, the general population, once their "act"/app caught on). These bands couldn't always sing, but they used technology to help them get a marketable product out, similar to how startups make up for their inexperience by using frameworks and web services to make their product improve, so they could continue to release "new records" regularly.
Over time, I've found that both the number of startups YCombinator has launched and the addition of the jobs page to news.ycombinator has shown that PG is actually not like a manager of boy bands, because the companies hire their own people and PG does not micromanage every decision, from what I understand. Also, I've noticed that media articles now describe these companies as their own beings, without always mentioning that these companies are part of YCombinator, something that is different from when YCombinator first started.
But yeah I couldn't get those.
While the title might have been a little aggressive it was how I was feeling today. I have seen a lot of stuff recently which is what brought this post about.
Hope I did not piss off anyone at Ycombinator (or the companies that they funded) as this post (if you read it you will see) is much more about the VC market changing and in my mind hurting the scrappy entrepreneur's chances.
I've done apartment hunting in the bay area, and it sucks. You have to look around, sign contracts, deposits, etc. It's a huge time and energy drainer.
I like your idea, I find it to be creative. Can someone please discuss the downsides to doing it this way? Let's put aside the whole "YC is dead" argument, that's obviously only going to degenerate this otherwise meaningful discussion.
It would be the ultimate extension of the Google (and Microsoft before them) "keep them at work" model. Bed, board, work in one location. Every cost could be amortized over the number of people/companies you have living there. Incomparable face to face networking opportunities.
Certainly one of those brainstorming "this is way too crazy to work...or is it?" kind of ideas.
I lived off campus for the last two years of college, and it made the experience suck a lot more.
This is the reason why I gave my upvote, nothing about a linkbait title or talk about VCs.
"So, if you’re just now starting up, don’t get blinded by the successes of the first people to realize a platform could be built and operated on the cheap. You already missed that wave. Now, unless you are extraordinarily lucky or well-connected, you aren’t going to succeed in publicizing your new service and getting up to a critical mass of content or subscribers or both unless you raise or have enough money to create initial awareness or value. There is too much clutter from which you must emerge."
Is it because VCs are being conservative right now? Will they be conservative forever? Is it because all business models are going to become failure in this economy? It capitalism dead?
And why the big building full of hackers? How is that entirely different than it is now? If they create self-sustaining businesses, is it necessary to have VCs?
Couldn't you build the business up using the traditional model of making money and then sell it off to a bigger company?
Article smells a bit link-baity to me. Use Y!C in any title and it's automatically going to climb to the first page here.
his alternative is to essentially do the same thing, but gear it not towards external funding/buying, but just a single company that grows, fosters and continually owns the companies it helps to start.
its sparse on the details, but i had/have similar thoughts and would love to start or participate in something similar.
...I believe that the Y Combinator model is dead. The idea that you can put something out there on the cheap, get traction and then raise a quick real round no longer seems to be valid. While there will always be exceptions to this rule, from what I can see the market for these companies to the VC’s is mostly dead.
He feels that way - how much more support do you need?
Btw, how many YC companies could you fund for the cost of buying a hotel in the Bay Area? 400? (assuming $6M for a hotel)
But the hotel idea is cool too.
Save up 30 or 40k. Quit your job. Take 6 months out to build your app.
But if you read the post I think the point I am making is clear and the title does fit that as well.
I would recommend writing to the audience you want to have, and nurture your current readership into loyalty through respect. That means reasonable headlines and fleshed out arguments.
I must admit though, I've toyed with the idea of a "dev bunker". Really cheap housing + coworking + startup community = super cheap collaboration.
I think PG is right, that it wouldn't be cheaper than the open market. But the benefit is in the colocation, not just cost.
There are plenty of YC companies that don't fit the super scrappy model though. We at Tipjoy have a house, for example.
I think it would be a lot cheaper. Getting contracts for office, housing, etc., is very expensive (both from a cash perspective and a business energy perspective).