This is what hype looks like.
This is what hype looks like.
Be the change.
Oh it doesn't? odd that.
ChatGPT cannot make judgement calls like what you're trying to imply it can.
ChatGPT can do some really cool things, but it's not magic.
maybe stop doing that.
The PDF example being thrown around in this thread. There's a magical step in the middle that no one is acknowledging.
You also realize that OpenAI has a dedicated Document Assistant which will literally extract information from a document you upload using prompts? Are you just unable to get that to work? I just don't know what you arguing at this point, like you're watching people walk backwards and then yelling that it's impossible for humans to walk backwards.
When I'm frustrated, I talk to ChatGPT like that.
It works as well for the LLM as it does for the humans in this thread.
What's worse is, I'd been writing some SciFi set in 2030 since well before Transformer models were invented, and predicted in early drafts of my fiction that you'd get better results from AI if you treated them with the same courtesies that you'd use for a human just because they learn by mimicking us (which turned out to be true), and yet I'm still making this mistake IRL when I talk to the AI…
You understand that If I want to extract the Date a letter was sent, who the recipient was, what amount is due on an invoice, etc that I have to send a specific prompt asking that to GPT with the PDF in the context? Do you just literally not know how this works?
With LLM at GPT4 level ability and a modest investment in scraping, context, building an agent based tool you can automate the entire thing with a pretty high precision and recall (such as a 0.9 precision with a 0.8 recall, vs 0.4 / 0.5 for humans). Using classical NLP, schema matching, and classification techniques you could triage and improve human performance by as much as 20%. But that requires a lot of effort and provides important but modest improvements. The LLM approach however is almost effortless from an engineering effort (note all of the infrastructure is the same as the NLP/schema matching/classification/etc effort).
This may not seem earth shatteringly important to you, but for an enterprise this is monumental. It dramatically reduces risk, complexity, cost, and all the while improves outcomes by an enormous amount.
Another example is incident management. Having LLM agents monitoring incidents on slack as reduced our MTRR dramatically. They provide summaries for new joiners, broad cast management updates, etc, and take care of all the glue out response teams typically did but with a high degree of quality, low degree of variability, and extremely low latencies compared to humans.
Another example is policy management. Many enterprises are saddled with thousands of pages of external requirements from regulators, and those in turn create tens of thousands of pages of policy, and hundreds of thousands of LoC of control implementations. By indexing them into a Context+RAG LLM you can create a policy oracle, allowing you to create coverage and effectiveness testing, analyze for policy or control gaps, draft responses to auditors and regulators with total policy knowledge, answer legals questions, advise management on the implications of a business driven exception, etc. The state of the art before was a search engine dumping phrase based matches into a grid of thousands of rows of results, which was effectively useless for all of these use cases.
followed by
> GPT4 level ability and a modest investment in scraping
oh yeah, these speech patterns are those of someone who isn't unnecessarily hyped while trying to downplay other approaches.
no bias here at all folks...
It’s readily apparent from the pessimistic HN threads they come from people who don’t actually do these things for a living and haven’t had much real world experience. These speech patterns as you call them are the way people who “do things” differentiate from those who can’t or haven’t done things. It’s called “experience.”
When claude shannon first came out with his information theory everyone started trying to apply it to everything, discuss everything in terms of his theories.
He himself thought it was ridiculous and basically told everyone to stop it.
This is no different.
Right now, I have to copy+paste my input and outputs, but my next task will be to write a Tampermonkey script to automate it.