Up to 7 years is what people get for grand larceny, for instance stealing a $1200 TV. 5 to 15 years you get for grand larceny in the second degree, for instance stealing a $50,000 car.
I don't know what the right punishment for SBF is, but I'm pretty sure what he did is worse than stealing a car, by several orders of magnitude.
Mandatory sentencing is grotesque, as would judges be who unjustifiably hand out maximums because they are having a bad day. But the ranges are there for a reason, allowing a judge to apply judgement.
I agree that 5 years is soft but regardless of the scale of the finances involved 100 years is an incredibly severe sentence for what is ultimately a nonviolent crime.
Most people who have actually killed a human being with their own hands get a chance at parole after 20-35 years.
Imagine this scenario:
1. Scammer defrauds a person for $$$
2. Scammer is caught
3. Scammer goes to jail
4. Scammer gets out
5. Scammer goes back to step 1
vs 1. Scammer defrauds 5 people
<repeat the same sequence as above and then return to defrauding 5 people>
vs 1. Scammer defrauds 50 people
until you get to thousands of people and companies a la SBFThe first case of one scam at a time will end up spending more time in jail than SBF despite defrauding far fewer people. Is that fair/just? We have plenty of other crimes where we consider the penalty for many crimes at once to be the same (if not worse) than count * penalty, so it's not just.
I'm in favor of a criminal justice system that is less about retribution and more about rehabilitation. But SBF isn't anywhere near the top of the list of people who got unfairly harsh punishments, not even if he gets that 100 year sentence. In a different -- and better -- criminal justice system SBF wouldn't have to spend the rest of his life behind bars. But in the current system he should, or it would be yet another exception for a rich and highly connected guy, which is also a type of injustice.
To me I feel you could make a strong argument for that being at least manslaughter if not murder (as I understand it, any death that occurs as the result of a criminal act is considered murder, and suicide as a result of fraud seems to fit that bill to me).
Framing this kind of crime as "non-violent" and so not deserving of a severe penalty is not far removed from "saying stealing that cars brake lines was non-violent so it's unfair to severely penalize the criminal just because of the later outcome"
It's not just stealing some money and the other people who steal even more should also get similar sentences.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m pretty much the opposite of an SBF sympathizer, but still, it is my opinion that stealing money should not get one a life sentence.
We should continue to try and catch and give consequences to the people we can, else how many more people will join the ranks of those who already do pilfer.