But I find these arguments much easier to understand if you look at it through that lens. Of course magic can cure cancer because… it’s magic!
But I find these arguments much easier to understand if you look at it through that lens. Of course magic can cure cancer because… it’s magic!
I don't think it's a coincidence we're seeing the largest numbers ever of people leaving organized religion at the same time we're seeing so many communities like the one that's grown around AI spring up that are essentially religion without the historical baggage.
There is no evidence that AI that's useful enough to help make research breakthroughs can be replicated orders of magnitude more quickly and cheaply. Whilst that's a true fact about software, AI is not just software -- it requires a lot of hardware. And currently it's far less efficient at using that hardware for general purpose problem solving than humans are.
For example, reading an MRI or other medical scan correctly goes a long way toward curing cancer. Reading it incorrectly wastes precious time as problems are ignored or mistreated with the wrong methods. I knew someone whose bone cancer was mistreated as a rotator cuff injury for a little over a year due to the fact that an inexperienced and probably overworked doctor did not correctly identify it in the slew of tests and scans the patient had taken.
In the future, it is likely that AI will always read these scans and test results more accurately than a human physician, leading to higher remission success rates. This will happen fairly quietly and behind the scenes, even if AI doesn't invent the magic cancer pill.
Of course, at the lowest levels it’s entirely understood but it’s the emergent properties that give many the feeling of magic — and I would argue quite reasonably so.
…for people who use ‘magic’ to refer to things that accomplish complicated tasks whilst abstracting it all away so that it looks easy (much like how I can copy and paste between my iDevices on a LAN and it magically works), anyway.
> Of course magic can cure cancer because… it’s magic!
If you take magic to mean something supernatural, then yes. It’s essentially of the same form as ‘god is perfect; a god that exists is greater than a god that doesn’t; therefore god exists’-type arguments.
The problem is that this makes almost anything sound reasonable, besides things that violate the laws of physics.
I don't think that thinking this far out is anything but pure speculation. Whether the mechanism is human intelligence, AI, or magic.