How does that make sense? Signal just made phone numbers for contact discovery optional, in which case this person still couldn't find their mother, even though Signal has their number on file.
What people are asking for is for phone numbers to be optional for account creation and identification. Everybody that wants to could still provide (and verify) their phone number for contact discovery, and this could even remain the default for non-sophisticated users as the one described above.
So that seems more like a retroactive justification for an early design choice (Signal was originally TextSecure and used SMS as a transport layer, so making numbers the primary key made total sense back then). The only thing that still makes sense to me today is spam prevention:
> Requiring phone numbers also makes it considerably harder for spammers to abuse Signal. “The existence of a handful of small apps that don’t really have a large scale of users, that don’t require phone numbers, I don’t think is proof that it’s actually workable for a large-scale app,” Whittaker said.
One possible solution could be to tie numberless account creation to a nominal donation payment: Still not great, but spam prevention is unfortunately not free to Signal either.
SMS is afaik the only real barrier they have to preventing that.
[0]: As in, AGPL and effectively a source dump with no instructions.