People while also all including tends to bring with it the identity war with it.
I use folks as a 1:1 to avoid the above.
People while also all including tends to bring with it the identity war with it.
I use folks as a 1:1 to avoid the above.
It's a shibboleth that says to others that you've been told that "people" has negative connotations and you are willing to adjust your speech based on what you've been told, but said negative connotations are not actually present in any dialect of English I've ever heard spoken.
Used that way it's a shibboleth. Used by DeSantis it's a part of Southern U.S. English.
I've even seen people spell it "folx" in writing to make it clear that they're using it as a shibboleth, since as you note it can be ambiguous in the absence of other dialectical markers.
Re: foreigners, this whole discussion is very US-centric, when I say "dialects" I'm talking about different varieties of US English, not anything outside the US.
If you naturally use it because you genuinely believe people is offensive, then he's absolutely telling you to modify your speech, but that is because he thinks you are wrong and you are the problem and he directly disagrees with you and he's not shy about it, which I think is fine. There's no pretence at neutrality there, and if you are neutral then he's not saying what you think.
All the strange culture war accusations are made even stranger by weird assumptions like this -- I don't know a single human being who has a problem with the word "people". I'm sure someone out there does, but I would conjecture that the vast majority of people -- even the folks you think of when using the word "culture war" -- have no problem with it
> People while also all including tends to bring with it the identity war with it.
I agree with you that I don't know anyone who has a problem with the word "people", but I do know several people (now including OP) who believe that some people do and make an effort to use "folks" to appease those (as far as I can tell fictional) people.