I would prefer websites just be websites and that we don’t have every single damned API available to whatever trashy site I accidentally click on, but I guess you and me are outliers here. Most people on HN seem to welcome every single JS API because web development is the only platform anyone seems to care about any more.
Things like this make for a more annoying web all around, because now it’s just one more tool sites can use to track me and increase engagement. (Edit: sibling poster chuckles said it way better than I can.)
If I had my way, JavaScript on the web would be limited to XMLHttpRequest and basic DOM manipulation and couldn’t do anything else. A totally separate “rich” JavaScript engine could be opted into by the user for any website that presents itself as an “application” like ones that legitimately want audio API’s like these. All these half-baked web app “standards” that google is forcing down our throats can be confined to that leper colony.
Then the most important bit: browsers could let me completely disable the “rich” engine, and I can go back to having a sane web experience again.
It also means you can tell the browser to outright deny every request, thus avoiding even getting prompted. If a website detects the request was denied and still prompts you any other way, that’s an undeniable signal to close the tab and never return.
The result is that the web just keeps getting incrementally worse and worse. It’s all good intentions in creating these API’s but the result is that everything just gets more terrible.
That’d let users turn support for all the fancy bits off by default and enable them in the tiny handful of cases that they’re actually desired. This way as far as sites are concerned your browser simply doesn’t support those features and thus can’t nag you.
And I'm all for focusing on technical security, but it's worth mentioning that the biggest most concentrated win would be making commercial digital surveillance illegal (ie the path the GDPR tries to head in). Imagine if large public companies had to make their revenue by honest means instead of working as advanced persistent threats.
There's value here. Other people are allowed to want more than you want.
I use photopea all the time now. it's available on every machine, even machines I don't have permission to install software on
I wouldn't trust a browser sandbox all that much given the high interest in subverting it.
Sorry, I’d prefer to stick with my operating system, not install QubesOS.
So when you make a meme or whatever and repost it somewhere else, guess what, they know who did that!
It really isn't it's extremely janky and buggy, only use it as an absolute last resort.