In addition to this being pretty mean-spirited, I'm also fairly certain it's wrong. I have no trouble coming up with examples of the adjective "cogent" modifying a noun indicating a person; you can quickly find one such example ("one of the most cogent writers") in the archives of The Atlantic, and all over Google Scholar. I dug through every usage of the word "cogent" in the New Yorker and, while it took awhile, I did find a couple. Alas, there was no section in Garner's Usage Dictionary covering the use of the word, presumably because there's nothing controversial about it.
I think the jury is pretty well in: obviously, the word "cogent" describes the expression of an idea or an argument, not a person, directly, but idiomatically, a "cogent writer" is simply one who produces cogent output.