Just say no to flags-and-footprints (and SLS); say yes to large scale Mars activities.
This has too much chicken-egg problem built into it.
Also, the value of going to Mars is still highly speculative. Once we reach it with low-cost, smaller missions, it's going to be less speculative, and the risk/reward profile of sending huge spacecrafts will make them more viable.
I don't think this is true.
If the main value is getting credit for putting the first human there, and doing a few experiments on soil samples or somesuch, then it definitely wouldn't be worth scaling things up, the same way its not worth doing missions to the deep sea, Antarctica or the Moon at scale...
This is old thinking. I take the goal of self sustainable society on Mars very seriously. Will it happen in our lifetime? Probably not, but it is the goal we should be working towards.
I'm not being snarky (at least not intentionally). But you're saying a thing that is at the very least a superpower-level goal, if not a civilization-level goal, that is very clearly not a current priority, should. What's more you're saying it in a way as if it's completely self-evident that we should change our global priorities to focus on this without the slightest evidence supporting that assertion.
You're also probably grossly overestimating the cost. The SpaceX Starship program has been privately funded on a budget of ~$2 billion a year including all costs - research and development, construction, launches, etc. And once built it's expected to revolutionize space (again) sending launch costs to less than $10 million per flight, and price per pound to space into the low dollars! And once we can start transiting massive amounts of cargo to Mars, at a very affordable cost, colonization is very much within the domain of possibilities.
I would not contrast prices against NASA. NASA is largely used as a tool for pork and graft by Congress, that occasionally launches something. Their latest ship, the SLS [1], is literally reusing Space Shuttle era tech. I mean literally - the SLS is reusing refurbished Space Shuttle RS-25D engines, solid rocket boosters, and more. Managing to spend tens of billions of dollars over 13 years (and counting) to develop this is the special sort of talent you can only get from a company like Boeing.
So colonization will be costly, but it's nothing like a civilizational goal. It's just that our civilization only has governments mostly interested in fighting and dominating one another, just as has been the case for the entirety of human civilization. So we never really get to see what we could actually achieve if we tried. But what's finally changed is that these sort of grand achievements no longer require governments. Costs are plummeting at the same time private capital has skyrocketed. So the future looks brighter than ever!
In this regard, you can define scarcity and post-scarcity independently for every consumed resource.
We've been post-scarcity for oxygen since before we evolved; post-scarcity for water in most of the settled world; and now? Now we're post-scarcity for biros, photocopier paper, USB cables and wall-warts, and tchotchkes.
The only reason we're not post-scarcity for intellectual property is that we've created rules to induce artificial scarcity.
Have we? Our supply has been getting tainted with worrying levels of trace contaminants. If we had 100x as much atmosphere, maybe that wouldn't be an issue yet.
>post-scarcity for water in most of the settled world
https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/imminent-risk-global-wate...
Yes.
> Our supply has been getting tainted with worrying levels of trace contaminants.
Note that I wrote "oxygen" not "clean air". You're not literally asphyxiating, you're not even close.
> https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/imminent-risk-global-wate...
"""Globally, 2 billion people (26% of the population) do not have safe drinking water and 3.6 billion (46%) lack access to safely managed sanitation,"""
As you quoted me, most of the settled world. Most. As in, more than 50%.
For small crewed ships, shielding will be the dominant part of the overall cost; for large ships it will be a negligible part of the whole cost.
Since we're mostly talking water, any moon water doesn't have to pay the rocket tax to launch from Earth surface.
And for a recurring trip, it'd make way more sense to keep a larger transit ship continually in either orbit or transit, with smaller barebones Earth/Mars cargo/crew transfer craft at either end.
I do like the picture though of a lunar mass driver that sends up regolith, metal, or something like that to a catcher at, say, the L1 point.
For a return trip you could use Phobos and Deimos for material. They are also extremely easy to land on.
(I assume Musk will announce one that looks like a famous 80s Sci Fi thing soon after Starship actually manages a round trip to Mars).
People need to stop thinking small.