The thing is, if this becomes commonplace, the Bittorrent protocol will just be modified to avoid it. I've had this happen occasionally - you get hundreds of peers feeding you junk data which wastes bandwidth. Torrent clients automatically ban a client after it sends too many bad parts, so the torrent would probably finish eventually, it'd just be a waste of bandwidth waiting to get connected to a legitimate peer.
If I understand it right this is essentially a DDOS tool. It surprises me that MS would help fund this.
Exactly. IANAL, but I'm pretty sure the law doesn't care who you're DDOSing. Making it ok to DDOS anybody is a slippery slope, so I would guess that this is illegal in pretty much any 1st world jurisdiction.
It's interesting that their first client was a Russian film. Looking at my Russian friends, I thought predominately pirate from non torrent sources (vk for instance). Anyone have a good sense of what the Russian pirate scene is like?
Looks like, that this tool is still baseed on traffic analysis. As a result, Bittorrent, probably, will start forcing clients to use secure connections both - to peers and to trackers. And that will effectively kill any traffic analysis attempt.