Bizarre paradox where a group is disenfranchised enough in academia it needs to protest dissent yet it can consistently expel people from it for disagreeing.
Bizarre paradox where a group is disenfranchised enough in academia it needs to protest dissent yet it can consistently expel people from it for disagreeing.
The very very large majority of requests to deplatforming are not followed by deplatforming. There are _tons_ of university and _tons_ of people complaining. If the majority was reaching their goal, everyone would be deplatformed all the time. (there are plenty of deplatforming protests from the "left", but as much from the "right", just look at all the banning laws discussed in states like Florida, for example)
Also, why are they organizing a protest if they are the ones deciding of everything in the first place?
Academia can have an extreme concentration of leftist dogmatism while political society can have a far right one. Both can happen at the same time in different communities.
What I've said is that:
1) the majority of attempts are not successful, so "yet it can consistently expel people from it for disagreeing" is just incorrect, so there is no paradox.
2) the people organising or allowing the events in the first place are the one in charge. If indeed the "complainers" are in charge, how is that possible that the event got the initial green light, or that the event is not simply shut down by the ones in charge when they realise they don't like it?
3) attempts are from every directions. For example, Christian student groups are organising lobbying to deplatform some stuffs they don't like for ages. It feels like this idea that it's now "all leftist" is in fact slightly "now the leftists are doing what the others were doing all along, so long that we did not notice". (not saying it's not the case, just that it's slightly biased: people trying to deplatform something you think is fair to talk about are "against free speech", people trying to deplatform something you think is stupid are just "reacting normally")
I'll need to look at data on that before conceding or disagreeing. (Not your job I'll look later)
>the people organising or allowing the events in the first place are the one in charge
How come? If I go to a town square to speak and I get lynched, am I the one in power because I organized my speech?
You're extrapolating a lot of power from being able to allocate time in a anphitheater from the University.
>3
Sure but it's been some years since leftism has been the worst offender when it comes to harassment in universities. I very much am against when it is the right doing the harassment (Dylan Mulvaney comes to mind).
> How come? If I go to a town square to speak and I get lynched, am I the one in power because I organized my speech?
But people don't just "show up" to universities and, bam, they can jump on stage and do an event. The events are always vetted by the people in charge. The events and their contents are reviewed and agreed. If it was not the case, how do you explain that companies don't go there to do a "speech" that happens to promote their product, or that extremists communities cannot easily go there and do their sermon, or that politicians cannot just go there and do their campaigning?
> being able to allocate time in a anphitheater from the University
Do you ever participate to such process? (not an attack, a genuine question. Maybe I'm wrong on how I imagine it works)
For 3: How do you judge "worst offender"? As I've said, it's very tricky, especially if the harassment from the "right" has become the norm. Or worst, when the harassment from the "left" is partially organised by the "right" (https://observer.com/2017/02/i-helped-create-the-milo-trolli...)
But does it even matter to the initial argument? Even if the "right" was the worst offender, the metric used in the article is still flawed.
And even if the "left" is the worst offender, if there is 95% of "right-wing" events cancelled and 5% of "left-wing" events cancelled, then, the presence of 5% is the demonstration that the left-wing is not in power (otherwise, it would be 0%).
More realistically, left-wing is the worst offender because they are the one using the protest tool more, while the people in power are not left-wing, they are just trying to ease the protest, but would act the same way if it was a right-wing demand.
I would be surprised if you're suggesting equivalence between a usually quite well off and at least somewhat famous speaker being shouted at from a few people in a crowd (who are usually quickly escorted out by cops), to, for example, women in Texas wondering if it's safe to leave the state to get an abortion, or, a teacher in Florida having to hide a photo of his husband he usually keeps on his desk for fear of losing his job (or even facing criminal charges as a "groomer").
Corrupting an institution that's (unfairly) used as the arbiter for scientific truth is not insignificant.
It does not compensate, but that's one thing.
Another element that I find telling is that people talk about US academic sector as if the academic sector was not extremely international. If your very good and very true research is black-listed in leftism-dogmatic US universities, if it is indeed very good and very true, this article will be supported by universities in other countries.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide_denial#:~....
>Things are more complicated: some people get more fame and more founding that their work would normally require because they present themselves as cancelled. There are even "anti-leftist-dogma university" initiatives coming out, which means that right-wing academic will have an easy position available there while left-wing academics don't have any such advantage
I think the worst of the deplatformed people enjoy this fame, which is not great. I'm a lot less concerned about Milo's exclusion than I am of Xi Van Fleet's. Drawing the ~line of acceptability~ at human rights is fine but academia is drawing it at leftist interest.
That's a really good example: if another institution admits it happened, it demonstrates that institutions are not controlled by a cambodian-genocide-denial-dogma.
Same here: as some left-wing events were cancelled by another university, even they are not the majority of the cancellation, it demonstrates that universities are not controlled by a left-wing-dogma.
> I'm a lot less concerned about Milo's exclusion than I am of Xi Van Fleet's.
And your Milo is another person Xi Van Fleet: you are basically admitting that you base your impression based on people you think were unfairly cancelled because they have an opinion that you think is sensible.
I was not able to find cases where Van Fleet was cancelled in an university event (the large majority of the research results are about how she is cancelled, again, the "bad leftist" has probably done more for spreading her view than what her views would have been otherwise, as they appear to be not really original). But I'm pretty sure you can easily find a person who say that the right-wing is like the chinese communists based on their own experience, and I'm pretty sure the right-wing people will criticize this person as much as Van Fleet is, and will protest as much to their event if they have the opportunity and if this person gets as much media coverage as Van Fleet.
(also about "democratic western academia problem": I don't get how this argument is a "win". It's basically "right-wing people are so stupid they cannot even find a way to publish something true themselves". If what a right-wing person is saying is true, then you will have universities that will support them, just because supporting someone who tells something that is true is just very very beneficial for the university. On top of that, as said elsewhere, it's not like the whole power spectrum is left-wing, so they will have plenty of support. Imagine the level of effort it will need for the bad university-leftist-owners to chase down every academic that is not a left-wing dishonest conspiracists (being left-wing does not mean a scientist will accept to reject the truth) in the WHOLE WESTERN WORLD so they cannot get any level of power in any one western uni? And at the same time, there are plenty of academic people who are right-wing, have done very well career-wise)
A country club is extremely biased towards conservatism even if there isn't an all encompassing authoritarian mind control scheme for it.
Leftism is popular in Academia because of selection bias and not some huge conspiracy, I'm aware, but that is still a problem if it lets so much misbehaviour pass and keeps gaslighting critics.
>being left-wing does not mean a scientist will accept to reject the truth
I agree but it's been known to happen and it's been known to be brushed under the carpet. Although there has been recent cases of literal socialist conspiracies in Ivy League universities.
https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/harvard-university-professor-...
Even if indeed "academia is left-wing" (which I'm still not sure it's properly proven: everyone who said that appeared to just "feel it's the case" and turn out to have some sympathies with more right-wing values. Of course you think it's more left-wing if you see left-wing event and right-wing event in same quantities: the right-wing events are not "right-wing", they are just "normal", so you end up thinking "this uni is doing 50% of normal and 50% of left-wing, so it is left-wing". Not saying it's not the case, my problem is that if it is left-wing, I would expect it will be said by people who are less biased).
I was saying ... even if it is left-wing, it is interesting that you are attributing that to "selection bias". There are plenty of other hypothesis: - people in academia thinks a lot, and right-wing ideas are just not very good (I don't think it's true, but it's as charitable as 'selection bias') - approach in academia is more compatible to left-wing way of thinking - socio-economic and culture of people going to academia are more compatible to left-wing way of thinking - ...
> I agree but it's been known to happen and it's been known to be brushed under the carpet.
How is that relevant? It's like saying "academia is dominated by right-wing: we can see some collusion and then it being brushed under the carpet", such as whatever you can find by googling "pro-iran academia in us" or any other right-wing dictatorial countries.
I love how Americans are so brainwashed about "the communist threat". I'm sure there are sometimes political games from China, sometimes linked to ideology (and maybe the example you gave it's indeed one of them, big deal, there are plenty of fraud done by right-wing academics), but in the majority of the cases, China involvement in frauds is just because China is a big country with an emergent economy, with a lax regulation to fraud supported by a corrupted dictatorship. China would have been a right-wing dictatorship, the same thing would have happened. But again, you are doing a confirmation bias: you want to see reason why academia is ideologically communist.
It does not change anything to the initial argument: what you call a paradox is not a paradox. You are just pretending here that someone the students who do the protests are the one in charge of vetting the events they are protesting about in the first place, which is just stupid.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_Socialist_Ba%27ath_Part...
It's the most deadly conflict of the region and it's brushed off because it's the fault of a socialist dictator.
I am not right wing. Last election I voted for a socialist union leader despite not being socialist. As someone in academia I'm frustrated with so much corruption and harassment and bullshit passing off as science by leftists. This is where I come from.
>I love how Americans are so brainwashed about "the communist threat". I'm sure there are sometimes political games from China, sometimes linked to ideology (and maybe the example you gave it's indeed one of them, big deal, there are plenty of fraud done by right-wing academics), but in the majority of the cases, China involvement in frauds is just because China is a big country with an emergent economy, with a lax regulation to fraud supported by a corrupted dictatorship.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Document_Number_Nine
Their intention is ideological, the goal is to destroy liberal democracy, this is documented. Yes the far right would do the same. I argue they are the same movement.
> It's the most deadly conflict of the region and it's brushed off because it's the fault of a socialist dictator.
Are you serious? "because it is a socialist dictator"? Iran regime is extremely criticized in academia, the idea it's a deadly horrible regime is a very agreed consensus. And Syria too, by the way.
(edit: and if you say "but it's what I see locally in USA, maybe it's not the case worldwide", you shoot yourself in the foot: you were saying that the whole western academia is left-wing and stand by the same goals of cancelling some opinions. If some opinions are cancelled by the big bad lefties in US but not in Europe, then again, they are not cancelled: their thesis will be largely published in Europe, and the big bad lefties in US will be exposed as fraud)
Also, political game is not as simplistic as "Syrian are socialist, I'm left-wing so I will pretend they are great": tons of left-wing people are very harshly critical of left-wing countries and inversely. Take Russia for example: while historically communist and with still strong roots to it, _some_ left-wing politicians will tend to minimize all their fault, but _some_ right-wing politicians will tend to minimize all their fault because their are politically allied with the nationalist Putin (cf. Trump who said he admires some aspect of Putin and minimises his crime). Because of that, _some_ left-wing politicians recognize in Putin a right-wing ally and are against Russia.
They idea that the "left-wing academia" "brushes under the carpet" crimes of Iran because a blind allegiance to the word "left" when in practice their ideologies are very incompatible is just ridiculous.
> I am not right wing.
What I mean is: if there is a bias, it should be raised by people who are also supporting what this bias support.
Once again, there is someone saying "they are left-wing" and then say "and I don't like the way they are left-wing".
As I've said, if someone is fair, promote 50% left-wing and 50% right-wing, people who don't agree with the right-wing direction will say they are right-wing and people who don't agree with the left-wing direction will say they are left-wing.
> As someone in academia I'm frustrated with so much corruption and harassment and bullshit passing off as science by leftists. This is where I come from.
Ok, so you are extremely biased. I'm sure you may have had very bad experience. But in science, we know that opinion from someone who had bad experience is extremely unreliable, especially if they have to judge the general environment after being confronted to a very small part of it.
No wonder you think all academia is left-wing if you have experienced a small part of it where there was things you've found unjust and that you attributed it to left-wing reasons.
> Their intention is ideological, the goal is to destroy liberal democracy, this is documented. Yes the far right would do the same. I argue they are the same movement.
You realise that this document is not the result of ideology, but that the ideology this document depicts is the fake justification to attack the other country, right? If they are against "western values", it's not because they really are against "western values", it is mainly because they need a justification to depict a concurrent country as "bad".
As you said, if US was more left-wing and China more right-wing, the same document would explain why left-wing politics is bad and they are against it.
Americans are really brainwashed about "the communist threat". Other powerful countries, especially dictatorships, are threats. China is a threat. The stupid idea that China is the enemy "because of the communist ideology" is ridiculous. They are the enemy because they are a concurrent country and that USA is preventing them getting more power. While Russia is becoming more complex because it's both communist and popular amongst right-wing nationalists, Russia is as much as a threat to USA (and there too, there are numerous documents proving their political interference for their profit).
And it is also deforcing your previous arguments: academia is left-wing, so they love China because they are left-wing too, while at the same time, China is planning to kill them all. It's so ridiculously simplist. You seem to think every left-wing person is very very stupid. Even if some left-wing persons are stupid (and they are), your whole reasoning falls apart when you have one non-idiot left-wing person who says "wait, I'm left-wing, I like the left-wing ideology, but what China wants is not at all what I want, because they want to rule over me instead of me being able to do my own socialist adventure. So, wait a minute, I will not protect China, I have absolutely no reason to do so".
From this whole discussion, it just looks like to me that you were in an unfair situation, and that you rationalised the situation with "it's because they are left-wing" (which may be true, or not, people always blame it on the ideology instead of thinking that maybe these people were just dicks, independently of their ideology), and because of that, now, you see proofs everywhere that the big bad academia is both dishonest and left-wing.