Google prevents Gemini AI from answering questions about upcoming elections
techcrunch.com
techcrunch.com
Nobody should be trusting an ai chat bot at this stage in the technology to give them "facts" let alone political arguments in important elections.
Bullshit like this is exactly why they're avoiding it.
Added: "I'm still learning how to answer this question." is very misleading and confusing. Instead of this, the response should be explicitly marked as policy-filtered and give the link to provide more contexts on the decision.
The even smarter play would be to shut down the user-facing service for the 3 months leading to the election.
Tiktok, modern food, LLMs... all sugary colorful substitutes for the real thing. We are supposed to be moving away from this empty stuff, except for major corporations that are just as guilty as the teenage perpetual Tiktok browser.
Whether or not you want to call an LLM an "AI" or not is really immaterial though, and more often than not just a distraction. Users have found conversational answer engine products like ChatGPT and Gemini valuable. They don't have to be perfect to provide value, but their imperfections are ripe for tarnishing the brands of long well established companies. But LLMs also have uses outside of a conversational answer engine; I for one am excited to watch them deployed in games, and also writing unit tests for code.
[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39688590 [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39689167
They did it with Bard. Why not again?
Good: Could a group create biased indexed web pages with SEO-like techniques so Gemini could had been used to affect the elections? That could put Google in hot water.
Bad: Refusing to answer questions takes an active role, and that could be used by political actors to shape hoe misinformation or influencing campaigns are presented so trying to verify or ask for them will get refusals for some demographics and answers for others.
Ugly: Announcing that they are doing this, so having this capability, doesn't tell what other things that can be seen as manipulation they might be doing but not announcing it, in this or another moment of time, or restricted to some people/sector/country.