Hacker News Reader

A cool tool to be sure.

However I feel this tool is a crutch for the stupid way browsers handle web pages and shouldn't be necessary in a sane world.

Instead of the bullshit browsers do where they save a page as "blah.html" file + "blah_files" folder they should instead wrap both in folder that can then later be moved/copied as one unit and still benefit from it's subcomponents being easily accessed / picked apart as desired.

View on HN

"save as [single] html" or whatever hasn't worked reliably in over a decade. I wrote a snapshotter that i could post in a slack alternative "!screenshot <URL>" and it would respond (eventually) with an inline jpeg and a .png link of that URL. As i mentioned upthread, this worked for a couple of years (2017-2020 or so) and then it became unreliable on some sites as well. as an example, old.reddit.com hellthread pages would only render blank white after the first couple dozen comments.

I haven't had the heart to try it with singlefile, but now that there's at least 3 tools that claim to do this correctly, i might try again. This tool, singlefile (which i already use but haven't tested on reddit yet) and archivebox. 4 tools, if you count the WARC stuff from archive.org

Reply on news.ycombinator.com