What practices are used that constitute good treatment with dignity? And what animals are you talking about, and producing what goods?
I ask because I find that most people who say stuff like this think that a dairy cow with access to open pastures is treated well, and with dignity, but then overlook the fact that the animal is routinely artificially impregnated, separated from their calf over and over and over again, and then killed at a quarter of her natural lifespan because her milk production is no longer economically beneficial to the company that "owns" her.
I'm not trying to say that that's the case here, just trying to get specific because I talk with a lot of people who say similar things as you, and I want to know if you're saying something substantially different or not.
So if you argue against all meat consumption by humans, then it is true: no keeper of animals can be considered "fit for keeping humans". Even a small farm purely for the owner's own consumption places restrictions on the livestock's freedom and ultimately keeps them so they can be eaten. Even animals that we keep as pets could be considered to live in inhuman conditions, because we restrict their freedoms.
I can't think of another situation in which one could choose to kill an animal for pleasure at 10% it's lifespan, and think that this was kind or respectful. Can you?
No, it's just part of the "circle of life".
Humans also interact with their environment and eat non human life forms (plants, cows, etc).
If we prove that trees have consciousness, will we need to stop killing them as well? Where does it end?
As for the tree hypothetical, why don’t we cross that bridge when we get there.
Humans have a capacity of reasoning about their actions, which places a certain responsibility on us to do better than nature. But where do you draw the line?
Ultimately we shouldn't eat animals at all - we should eat lab grown meat. But lab grown meat is still far away. So what do we do in the mean time? Ban all meat consumption? Is that even realistic?
Those with access to all the makings for a healthy plant-based diet should stop paying for animal products. It's that simple.
Is growing vegetables also inhumane, since we're controlling every aspect of those plants' lives?
Is doing pest control in your own house a mass murder, because you're killing a colony of cockroaches or termites?
Is washing your hands a genocide, because you're killing millions bacteria and tiny parasites on your hands?
That kind of extremist empathy is fatal to humanity. I'd rather choose to be cruel than dead.
> Imagine your children being born into one of these farms.
> You might argue non human animals are different, but why does that matter? Black and white people are different, why would that difference justify enslaving one group?
I don't claim to know where the exact line is, but thankfully, I don't have to, because the world doesn't run on ethical guidelines, it runs on power struggle. Grandparent was quick to draw the analogy to black slavery - I'd like to point out that black slaves were powerful enough to fight for their own freedom. Cows and chickens aren't. We're gonna eat them because that's just how the world works.
Of course, if someone very powerful becomes obsessed with animal rights, and uses political power to ban meat, I guess we'll stop eating them. I'd be very sad if that happens, but again, that's just how the world works.