Porsche Will Stop Selling Boxster, Cayman in Europe Due to Anti-Hacking Law
thedrive.com
thedrive.com
See also: UN extends its cyber security management regulation to motorcycles and scooters
26 January 2024
UNECE’s Working Party on Automated/Autonomous
and Connected Vehicles today decided to include
motorcycles, scooters and electric bicycles
with speed exceeding 25 km/h in the scope of
the UN Regulation No. 155 on cyber security and
cyber security management.
https://unece.org/media/transport/Vehicle-Regulations/press/...How hard could it be to fix whatever is causing it to fail the legal requirements, compared to the cost of terminating multiple product lines in a key market? There must be more to this than what is being reported.
Why are none of the news articles going into detail about the exact nature of the problem?
From a political perspective I am surprised that Germany didn't insist on delaying the deadline to minimize impact on their domestic car industry. Maybe something has them spooked about cyber security risks?
And if it's as you say, then who ratified such a ridiculous rule, and why? The UN is not supposed to be a legislative body. At least, that's what I've been saying when I find myself going toe-to-toe with conspiracy theorists.
The MCU's used in these systems are very often pushed to the limit with resource consumption hovering at 80% of flash and RAM. Ram is usually from then to hundreds of kilobytes. Bigger systems could be retrofitted with some effort. Small systems you need to redesign, highly likely having to replace them MCU. Highly likely you'll have to then redesign the whole board layout. At that point you're essentially just doing a new ECU and we'll... For previously existing lines of products it's probably not worth it.
There are probably _some_ options though if you get creative. I'd honestly suggest killing the software update capabilities of established lines, then the UNECE class can be switched to something that doesn't require these things and call it a day?
But it doesn't answer my question: why is Porsche getting dunked on to the apparent exclusion of everyone else? They don't do any of this stuff themselves, and haven't for a very long time. They share control units, gateways, and peripherals with multiple manufacturers. Yet nobody else in the EU seems to be catching all this grief.
I don't really care, because my Macan and Boxster are 4 and 11 years old respectively and aren't going anywhere. They no longer make anything I want at a price within my toy budget. But there just seems to be an element of unfairness here that doesn't make sense, and I'm curious to hear the real story.
They might also have _other_ projects in the pipeline that they would rather spend the resources on . Lose some income from existing lines but make it up with the others kind of deals.
And the third possible alternative is they got caught with their pants down. They might not have taken this UNECE thing seriously and not made contingency plans and simply... Not have enough time to execute before they are not able to sell any more cars of that kind untill they fix it.
If it's _that_ important for you, I can ask around at friends in the industry and let you know what I find out what is going on there. You can drop me an email at my contact I have in the profile.
I've heard a (credible) stat that there's more Mercedes-Benzes sold in California alone than in the entirety of Germany; if these numbers hold up (outside the EU) for Porsche I could understand them giving up on the EU
This is probably not far from true for Porsche too today, honestly. The Porsche Macan/Cayenne are increasingly mass-selling mass-produced mainstream luxury family car products much like BMW/Mercedes used to dominate in 90s/2000s, and they sell really, really well.
We've reached the stage sadly Porsche is an SUV company that happens to sell some sports cars.
2023 North American sales: 86,059
2023 German sales: 32,430
A very large chunk of that 86k will have been CA.
> https://newsroom.porsche.com/en/2024/company/porsche-deliver...
[Application for approval] shall be accompanied by the
undermentioned documents *in triplicate*
Porsche is holding the line on killing trees.https://unece.org/sites/default/files/2023-02/R155e%20%282%2...