The issue here isn't about trusting Git or tarballs, is about trusting developers. If you do not trust the developers then getting the code via Git or tarball wouldn't make anything more trustworthy and if you DO trust the developers then there is no reason to trust the Git more than the tarballs since they are both provided by the same people who you already trust to not insert malicious code in the project.
And if there is any relevant lesson from the xz case isn't to trust Git more than tarballs but - as someone else mentioned already - tarballs should be fully reproducible from Git.
You are talking about this from hindsight. For other projects, we do not know yet if anything similar is happening. So for them the Git repo is definitely more trustworthy.
> tarballs should be fully reproducible from Git.
That's exactly the same as trusting Git repo more than the tarball.