They are arguing that publishers should release an end-of-life patch to allow players to host their own servers.
Read the FAQ: https://www.stopkillinggames.com/faq
They are arguing that publishers should release an end-of-life patch to allow players to host their own servers.
Read the FAQ: https://www.stopkillinggames.com/faq
It may also not be an easy task, especially if it isn't a simple single service you start up and it's microservices or whatever. That is before getting into the question on whether or not there are certain parts of the system that are shared with other games that simply can't just be put out for release.
Oh no, it might not be an "easy task" to undo all their planned obsolescence. Shucks. Maybe they should have thought of that before they planned the obsolescence in the first place.
Seriously, in most cases it will be completely trivial to do, especially single-player games.
(Yes, single-player games are routinely getting killswitched by spiteful publishers. It's a fucking outrage.)
------
[It seems I'm rate-limited so I can't reply further, but I have noticed in this thread a lot of people who don't seem to understand all the context behind this, making a lot of naive and ill-informed points. There are dozens of examples of publishers killing games for arbitrary/spiteful reasons, that have nothing to do with the cost it would take to provide an alternative. Ross Scott has many documented cases on his channel, see here https://www.youtube.com/@Accursed_Farms/search?query=dead%20...
We're not just talking about always-online multiplayer games here. It's also games with single-player campaigns that are rendered unplayable by the deactivation of a central auth server. Or games with a co-op component that are now unplayable because it's gated behind a centralized matchmaking system that shut down. Or games with libraries of shared player-created levels that are now inaccessible, like Super Mario Maker.
Also I have to say, I'm flabbergasted at the unthinking deference being shown to enormous conglomerate publishers in this discussion, and the focus on one side of the ledger to the exclusion of the other. People are saying that this will impose a cost on corporations, and this is in and of itself a reason to reject it. Like ... yes, of course regulations impose a cost on businesses! Obviously! The idea is that this small cost will be offset by a larger increase in consumer welfare. Just saying "this will impose a cost on business" is a fully-general counterargument against any kind of consumer-protection regulation. Nevermind the ethics of it -- people should fucking own what they pay for and they shouldn't have the rug pulled out from under them!
As for the idea that it is too complicated to self-host a modern multiplayer game: this is Hacker News, not Never-Bother-To-Even-Try News. Mod communities have done impressive feats in reverse-engineering game servers. It can be done.]
In no way is a game shutting down planned obsolescence. If the Fortnite servers are shut down that's not planned obsolesce, that game does not work and makes zero sense as a single play game. A publisher is not going to spend a ton of money working on a game with a plan to shut it down, they hope to milk it for money as long as they can.
I agree with single player games requiring always online, but I have not seen an example of this actually being the case that there was not a patch put out at the last moment to make the game not connect to a server anymore.
There is a major difference between a game requiring an online connection for a 100% single player game and an online games servers shutting down.
The first is bad and I agree and should never be a practice. The second is just reality.
Why not? Just unlock all in-game contents, replace other players with offline bots, then shutdown the servers. Many online games have chosen this route in the past.
This assumes that the content is all client side and some of it is not server side. As is the case with many games.
> replace other players with offline bots.
That requires work to make the bots know how to play the game, something that even actively supported games suck at. Many bots are really bad with objective based gameplay. and testing. Which is a cost if they are shutting down the game.
If the game was built around the assumption that it will always have an internet connection, there may also need to be a lot of changes to the game itself to operate that way.
Then such games shouldn't be sold as goods like the the petition mentioned. They should be sold as services like WoW, so their customers know what to expect at the end of the service. Selling them as goods is worse than selling "lifetime" membership for an SaaS, then closing the SaaS after 3 years, because the customers may not know that the game would become unplayable in a few years when they purchased it.
WoW you have to buy. Yes there is a subscription but you also have to buy the game and each expansion.
Destiny 2 you have to buy each expansion.
They are not selling a SaaS as a lifetime one time buy, I checked all of my xbox games and every single one makes it clear that they can change it at any point.
So it sounds like your argument is they just change the wording of something, charge the same amount, and then this proposal does nothing?
I don't really buy the argument that consumers don't understand that servers eventually shut down.
You don't "buy" WoW, their website explicitly ask you to subscribe (monthly or yearly) [1]. Yes, you can buy the expansion, but those wouldn't work without subscription. Customers wouldn't be duped into buying the game and expecting it to still working later when all the servers are shut down, so the petition problably wouldn't apply to WoW, though the petition mentioned about getting this kind of game to support some form of self hosted server support for at least a fraction of its features at the end of its lifetime.
You also don't "buy" Destiny 2, it's a free-to-play game. You can buy items and expansions like WoW. It's not as clear cut as WoW, but it's also should be clear enough that Destiny 2 is not sold as traditional goods, and the petition probably doesn't apply to this game as well.
The game mentioned in the petition, The Crew, was sold for $50 with single player campaign and online components just like other games usually do. Then the publisher made the game unplayable later, even though it has some single player campaign contents. What's their excuse for doing this? Is this game actually a service where it can be made unusable at any point? If so, it should be clear from the get go and the game shouldn't be sold as goods, so customers who want the game they bought to be playable indefinitely (minus the online components) can spent their money on other games instead.
[1] https://us.shop.battle.net/en-us/product/world-of-warcraft-s...
At one point you did buy destiny 2 just like you did the first one. While they changed their business model for the base game at one point the example is still a valid one. You could argue that their "free to play" part is largely a demo to get you to buy the expansion. FFXIV does the same thing. Same with WoW.
You buy those expansions for both games and in both situations when the servers shut down you loose access to something that you spent money on.
Regarding The Crew. Part of the problem here, and one of my biggest issues with this particular campaign, is it seems like we are arguing about 2 very different things and the main page paints one picture of what they want and the FAQ is something else.
To be clear, I have not played this game so I am trying to get information about what the actual reality of this game is and is not and that makes this a very hard conversation.
We have online DRM for single player games. Which I 100% agree with shouldn't ever be a thing. It makes no sense.
But then we have online games. Where being online is a fundamental part of the game and the server side component is required.
This petition seems to want to treat both of these equally where they are fundamentally different problems and the second one is far more complex.
I cannot find a concrete information on where The Crew actually falls for this. It has a single player component but is this actually all local content or was it engineered in a way to rely on something server side. I honestly don't know and we can speculate on whether it should have been or is and is not, but that is an important part of this conversation.
I don't think this distinction about traditional goods is as important as you think it is. As far as a consumer goes, when more games were physical. I could go and buy WoW, FF11, Destiny, whatever the same as I would any single player game. And I did, I used to physically buy all of the Wow expansions and it was up to the consumer to understand that it is an online game that may shut down one day. That isn't a hard thing to know.
My question is on how the game is built. Is the single player simply not working due to the entire game requiring being online or is there a part of the single player that relies on something that is online to work at all.
As in, is all of the necessary code to run the single player actually on the disk or not? No amount of showing me gameplay is going to answer this question unless someone has actually looked at the game itself or the network activity to determine what is actually happenjng.
That is not an uncommon practice in MMO's. WoW released in 2004 (it is not clear to me when exactly WoW did this practice, if it was from the beginning or a later change).
So it is entirely possible. Not saying it is necessarily the right way they should have made it, but it is a possible explanation that is an important part of the conversation.
The reason The Crew is specifically the target of this whole campaign is because it has an offline mode built into the code itself, the flag to change into this mode relies on an encrypted key. Currently this has not, or can't, be broken.
So not only did they shut the game down, they took active measures to make SURE no one would ever be able to run it again. Letting it live, (or at least giving the fans a chance to resurrect it) could be as simple as the company posting that encryption key on twitter.
That's why this is all so egregious, because it's not even developer incompetence or budget necessarily, it's greed and bordering on outright theft.
By the way, the guy who made this site goes by Ross Scott on youtube, he has a couple videos that explain everything. He's not a programmer, but probably has months of research into the legal aspects plus a small army of volunteers helping with the process.
In that case, I agree with the fact that the single player component should be made playable without needing to be online.
However I from what I can tell the person who has made the site also has pushed back against entirely online games and GaaS, which eventually shut down.
I stand by my opinion here that we are looking at a campaign that is talking about 2 massively different issues, trying to address them with the same thing.
The answer to this problem is simple, stop making actual single player games that require a constant internet connection.
Any talk about multiplayer games, MMO's, etc (in the FAQ) is making this entire discussion confusing and that is a very different problem to single player games being inaccessible.
P.S.: We forgot a couple of third-party libraries in there, so we'll be hit by a bunch of lawsuits because our private licenses for these libraries absolutely did not cover open-sourcing them for the whole world.