> In terms of power for an equivalent amount of storage the SSDs require much more (SSD and HDD use about the same amount of power).
O RLY?
Toshiba X300
4TB 16TB 10TB 8TB
Operating W 6.81 6.91 9.48 8.41
Idle W 4 4.03 7.22 5.61
Samsung 870 QVO 8TB
Operating W 2.4/3.3 (R/W)
Idle W 0.045
> But you're talking transient spin-up power of course which is significant and might require an external power supply which costs money
You need an external PSU for 3.5" HDDs because they require 12V and 5V. 870 QVO only require 5V.
> The physical space required is not significantly different
Come on:
3.5" HDD: 26 x 147 x 100 = 382200 mm3 (Toshiba X300)
2.5" SSD: 7 x 70 x 100 = 49000 mm3 (Kingston A400)
382200 / 49000 = 7.8
870 QVO is listed as "100 X 69.85 X 6.8 (mm)" so essentially the same
> Random IO bandwidth doesn't matter at all when you're putting it at the end of an ethernet connection to an rpi.
Ah, yes, because everyone is only doing sequential IO to NAS, like you?
Sorry, but you arguing here in a bad faith and without even a bits of a basic knowledge.