Big Tech Is Trying to Prevent Debate About Its Social Harms
foreignpolicy.com
foreignpolicy.com
But the article isn't about censorship. It seems to be about lobbying tactics in negotiations about international trade agreements that most people don't know about and have no access to.
I cannot find them right now but I recall the emails at Apple between Steve/Phil/Scott etc. regarding the ability to use apps on the iPhone. Probably one of the few times where some of the folks at the top were thinking about these issues. Steve was against it because of the potential for their phone to become something entirely different than what they intended it to be AKA a highly focused easy to use phone, media system with a little web browsing. An Apple product, by Apple to be used the Apple way.
But because of pressure from Android they opened up the App store because, essentially, "if we don't do it, they will be the only ones doing it.". While it worked wonders for their bottom line, you do have to wonder if long term it was the smartest move due to the blow back on it societal issues. But then, Android was already going this path so it was Apples game to lose to Google.
This is one of the key features of technology, if someone else can do something to gain an advantage over their competitors, it is in the best interest for the original group to also adopt said technologies of be left behind. If they opt out, it most likely means they will not survive into the future. On a larger scale, this applies to not only those that make this tech but how people use it. You may be against smart phones for instance but if almost everyone else is using them, you are practically forced to use a smart phone because society will be shaped by them.
Any time you hear someone justifying bad behavior with this sentiment, you know you're dealing with someone who is ethically and morally bankrupt.
Unfortunately, those that think like that usually go to the top because they will pull the trigger quicker than those that hold back and consider the consequences. They will always be 1st to the market. Then it just become a game of survivorship bias when thousands of folks try this, 99% get the blow back and fail but the ones that are lucky enough to ride that and weather the issues get rewarded immensely. AKA every billionaire.
This is why it seems like the social media that doesn't worry about their long term issue the most seem to do the best market wise. AT least for now. "Ethics be damned, get users by any means possible!". Facebook has been very reckless about this since they had their IPO, and it has worked until folks eventually conned on to it, but that time gap is huge and the damage unknowable. We are seeing a very extreme version of this at Twitter/X at the moment, with moderation being minimized, but it looks like that may a case were they went too far to fast and it is coming back to hurt them.
> The valuation of Y Combinator's companies is estimated to be at least $600 billion as of January 2023.
I.e. Garry Tan doesn't have direct authority in the same way that Sundar Pichai does.
If a nation wishes to get out of a treaty, it can simply refuse to follow it. If other nations don't like this, they can appeal to the supreme court of nations which is called war and let might decide who is right. Treaties are, and by their nature must be, at-will contracts that exist as long as all parties to them wish for them to continue to exist. Every treaty is as worthless as the Kellogg-Briand Pact[0] which purported to outlaw war until Germany, Italy and Japan suddenly decided to stop following it and start a second world war.
There are many other examples in political science where politicians have spun elaborate Gordian knots[1] that, for some reason, they pretend they cannot just cut with a common sword.
Article VI US Constitution ...
This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.
I'm curious to hear where are our crypto activists, robotics, and privacy activists that we used to have. The 3 laws of robotics used to be a hard thing that people respected. Now.. lol autonomous kill drones.
We as humans failed to instill morality unto the Minotaur of capitalism, it's our collective moral failure that allows it.
True, but that problem pre-dates capitalism by at least several thousand years--humanity has never managed to reliably instill lasting morality into any institution, not even those ostensibly centered on it.
In that view, it's not that companies are uniquely bad, but that the environment and ecosystem[0] doesn't constrain their tendencies.
[0]: Institusystem? Estabisystem? Whatever, obviously I don't mean biology.
Completely in agreement, it's just a general disappointment I have given that we are leaps and bounds more knowledgeable than at any point previously in history, even with all that knowledge about our past, about how systems work, incentives, etc. we haven't been able to tame the beast of greed and let it roam free to destroy as it pleases. It's just my wishful thinking that we should be better by this point but we aren't, that's not reality.
Is this supposed to be a marker of something meaningful? General Mills is not exactly a brand that exudes trust or consumer loyalty.
Stunning omission of Apple and Microsoft (OpenAI).