The maintainers are vetted before joining, and are removed if they do something untoward, but when the choice is between killing the project or giving it to some random person, Code Shelter provides a better alternative.
Fork the project. Earn your own trust.
This:
> I wish people would put their projects in something like https://www.codeshelter.co so anyone who's interested can maintain them, instead of just killing them
Forking the project and earning your own trust really is the safe path forward.