If IT investment brings low to no returns, what are we to make of the universal embrace of IT by the markets and absolutely humongous valuations and profits of the big tech? Are the markets being irrational for the last 50 years?
And yes, that difference is very hard to explain. One of the main sources of competitiveness (and the only that should be most clearly impacted by IT) is productivity.
Are measuring things wrong? Is there some other effect of IT that reduces the productivity to compensate? Is there something else happening that confusingly takes away all the gains from IT? (Perfectly correlated, for 50 years!?) Does plain logic break down due to some mechanism that nobody has found yet?
Nobody is certain about the answer, but theories abound.