Or the fact that the entire sales pitch is “this will be cheaper than actual people who know what they’re doing”, maybe a side claim of “outperforms people on our training set” coupled with “we accept no liability for inaccurate advice or poor outcomes”.
The sole purpose of programs like these is to save money. It has nothing to do with helping anyone. The goal is to sound like your system is providing the service people paid for, without actually spending the money to provide that service.
I will believe a company will is doing the right thing when the developers personally accept the criminal and legal liability that an actual doctor or nurse providing the service is subject to.
But then to add insult to injury this just further increases the wait time for people by forcing them to deal with the “AI” before they get through to the further reduced pool of actual specialists and correspondingly increased wait times there as well.
This is not rocket science to understand, and literally nothing I’ve said here is new - not the clear prioritization of cost cutting, the overselling of “AI”, and the generally unsafe use of randomized statistical models to provide factual information.
My question is why you think that this time is different vs literally every other example?
I'm as skeptical of GenAI as they come, but let's not pretend that the people working on GenAI customer support are the same people who should be working with the AMA to address the artificial constraints in medical education.
The thing I notice about every argument where I see "we can do both", is that in reality we never actually do both
That's why people get so adamant about choosing their way instead of the other way. There's always two options, we could do both, but we never, ever seem to
Let’s summarize the situation here. A group of people have chosen to work on GenAI customer support. You’re criticizing them for not working on a difficult political problem instead.
Meanwhile, what are you doing? Which of the political activist groups working on the problem you care about so much have you joined? How have you offered your support?
If this issue is so important to you that you think “we” should be devoting our full attention to it, surely you’re out front leading the charge, right?
>You don't think there's any conceivable way that this may actually help people?
I don't. I believe that exactly as OP described people will notice they are talking to some AI and just give up, as they correctly understand that the AI does not have the abilities and understanding that might actually help them.
Health things around here have legal restrictions that definitely prevent them from using GPT, thankfully.
This is why people are pessimistic about ML/AI in people-facing positions. It has happened with automation in the past, it is _currently happening_ with ML/AI systems in customer-facing applications, and the momentum of the field is headed in that direction. To me, it would be very silly to assume that the field would make a sudden 180 from decades of momentum in a rather established direction, with no established reason other than the potential for it to be good.
This is why people tend to generally be upset about it, is my understanding. It's a good tool, and it is oftentimes not used well.
I don’t interpret the OP as slamming AI. It’s criticism of the way in which companies find ways to save a few dollars.