Increasingly see such comments on HN. It is weird.
It's neither kind, nor curious.
It's not thoughtful or substantive.
It's specifically not responding to any points, data, arguments, etc brought up in the linked article.
It is absolutely sneering.
It reduces the conversation to just a single word or two in the title.
It is flamebait, tangential, and certainly tropey.
It is the definition of a shallow dismissal.
It is purely political and ideological.
It absolutely is picking the most provocative thing (in the title) and singling that out.