> Then Linux started transitioning from a patchwork of loosely coupled replaceable components to integrated stacks in the mid-2000s
I cannot imagine a better sales pitch for Linux as an operating system for people who actually want to use a working, reliable, well integrated, featureful, coherently designed, modern operating system to actually get really cool things done as opposed to people that want to endlessly tinker with a giant pile of glued-together parts.
I had a phase when I wanted to use minimal Linux distros and cobble together the individual components of my system of myself, with only what I needed and nothing more and making sure I understood how everything fit together, but I quickly realized that that's just not the way to produce a system that's actually nice to use and useful.
> ironically more and more of a corporate commodity rather than a playground for software freedom
Having an actually integrated set of system components and software stacks may make the system less modular, and so less free in some sense, but I don't think it takes away software freedom in a way that really substantially matters. FLOSS software can be tightly integrated and remain free. Especially when there is still so much modularity, and the trade-off is a much better system, which is worth it in my opinion. Also, I don't see why integrated software stocks are inherently corporate, although it is true that Linux is getting a lot of corporate funding.
> This is an entirely dependable, simple, hackable, grokable system and that's the way I want it to stay.
This desire to be able to understand absolutely everything on your system seems kind of absurd to me.
It is the primitivism, the going to live in a log cabin in the woods completely off grid using 1800s technology, of the software world — both in that the impulse to give up the benefits of the division of labor and modern society and economies, the ability to have people specialize in understanding and building things that you don't have the time to specialize in or build yourself, is just patently absurd and essentially reactionary, born out of a fear of the unknown, and because even such people find themselves inevitably depending on things that they don't fully understand or didn't fully do themselves. I guarantee you that you wouldn't be able to understand the full intricacies of all of the components on your system, including the compilers and the entirety of the kernel and all of the drivers and everything else, and that's not to mention your processor architecture or whatever.
And if your argument is that you understand the high level components and how they fit together, that is precisely as true for a system with larger components. My point is that any system beyond Forth running on bare metal is probably beyond the ability of any single person to actually understand fully and if you are okay with a certain level of abstraction that I don't see the difference.