House passes bill requiring warrant to purchase data from third parties
thehill.com
thehill.com
Edit: to the question “How would you define a data broker for these purposes?” that was deleted, I would defer to the CFPB’s criteria:
https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/remarks-of...
Because in practice, this bill does nothing.
Senior administration officials said the measure would blind U.S. intelligence outfits from getting information easily purchased by foreign intelligence operations
Right. And I'm supposed to believe that our intel people won't just use the data banks of British Intel or DGSE is that it?
Heck, our law enforcement people could use Homeland Security databases after the information is disseminated.
Without banning the practice of data aggregation in and of itself, you stop nothing.
ETA: Now I think about it, I guess it does stop a local sheriff from having his/her own database. But it does nothing to stop them from searching DHS databases and getting the same information. And of course, as far as federal intelligence and law enforcement, well, they would be custodians of the databases so... yeah.
I suspect that saying "no one should be able to sell people's data behind their back" would catch a lot more traction than "we should regulate this fuzzy idea of companies we don't think you should like." It would also solve the actual problem at hand.
Either way, the government accessing the data should absolutely require a warrant.
most importantly, it removes one potential lucrative buyer, making the business less profitable.
Maybe I need to spin up my own IdP and track every time an authorized Sp reads my data.
Been doing this for years. It’s something like $25/mo and gives you access to Google Admin where you can see logs and reports. Don’t think there’s prebuilt log reports for SPs calling APIs but pretty sure it’s possible to query that sort of data or log it into Google cloud
Data leaks will happen and at this point private industry can be just as bad as the state. What happens when private prisons purchase such information? Or other private institutions that have taken over government responsibilities?
It doesn't make anything impossible to get, even if there weren't clear workarounds, all the data is as accessible as it was so long as they get a warrant rubber stamped by a judge.
> “It can be impossible to know what’s in a data set before one actually obtains a data set,” the official continued. “So you’d be barred from getting that which you don’t even know.”
He says this as if law enforcement going on fishing expeditions isn't a dystopian nightmare that should never be allowed in the first place.
However, the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Amendments apply to the states via the Fourteenth Amendment, which explicitly states that "Congress shall have power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article." So state warrant requirements are not completely out of the reach of Congress.