This pdonis is a jackass - here are direct quotes from Dennett:
- "There is no reality of consciousness independent of the effects of various vehicles of content on subsequent action (and hence, of course, on memory)." - from Consciousness Explained, page 132.
On page 113 he says:
- "Unlike mental states taxonomized folk psychologically, "content-fixations" are each precisely locatable in both space and time".
^ he is saying mental states are not locatable in space and time.
Page 138:
- "There are no fixed facts about the stream of consciousness independent of particular probes"
An interview:
- "The reason [consciousness] is so puzzling is that people think they ought to be able to study it from the inside, using pure phenomenology, those give you hints but they are illusory. That's not what's really going on."
Source for this interview (New Scientist): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wm8M_xQrgCk
From David Rosenthal's Content, Interpretation, and Consciouness:
- "There is good reason, in any case, to construe Dennett's pandemonium model as positing only subpersonal events of content fixation, rather than full-fledged intentional states. Thus he writes:
"We replace the division into discrete contentful states-beliefs, meta-beliefs, and so forthwith a process that serves, over time, to ensure a good fit between an entity's internal information-bearing events and the entity's capacity to express (some of) the information in those events in speech. [10]
10: Dennett speaks throughout Consciousness Explained of such nonconscious, subpersonal events
Wikipedia on Multiple Drafts:
- "Dennett argues that [consciousness theories] share a common error in supposing that there is a special time and place where unconscious processing becomes consciously experienced, entering into what Dennett calls the "Cartesian theatre".
A couple more Dennett quotes:
- "There does not exist ... a process such as 'recruitment of consciousness' (into what?), nor any place where the 'vehicle's arrival' is recognized (by whom?)"
- "the Multiple Drafts model goes on to claim that the brain does not bother 'constructing' any representations..."
I could go on forever because this was his main jam. I find it hilarious this pdonis person has such a high karma/score/whatever on this site after such awful takes.
I won't even get into Searle who pdonis just Googled for the first time, bringing up Chinese Room (1980) as if it's a scientific theory. What a joke, I wish he could be downvoted.